As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
Sierra owners who shop for liners usually end up at the same fork: the GMC-branded set from the dealer’s accessory catalog or a WeatherTech kit. The weathertech vs gmc floor mats question looks simple until you try to order, because the two brands build their liners differently and sell them through very different channels.
We use the 2019-2024 GMC Sierra 1500 crew cab as the reference truck throughout. Every product detail below comes from the Amazon US listings, and where a listing leaves something out, we say so instead of guessing.
Quick answer
Should a Sierra owner pick WeatherTech or GMC liners?
Pick WeatherTech if you want both rows covered in one order, a stiff tray with tall edges, and a listing that names the 2019-2025 Sierra 1500. Pick GMC accessory liners if the logo and a factory look matter most, but confirm the GM part number against your VIN first.
Our Quick Picks
The WeatherTech FloorLiner and the GMC-logo accessory liner for the Sierra 1500, plus WeatherTech's flatter All-Weather Floor Mats for the same truck, each reviewed below.

WeatherTech FloorLiner 461436-1-2
Both rows in one order, with a stiff tray and a listing that names the Sierra years.

GM Accessories 84185474
GM's own premium all-weather liner, with the logo and a softer, OEM-style feel.

WeatherTech All-Weather Floor Mats
WeatherTech's softer, lower-profile option for owners who dislike a stiff tray.
Aftermarket Tray or Factory Accessory?
WeatherTech is an independent maker that scans each vehicle floor and molds a liner to it. Its FloorLiner uses a stiff, three-layer material with a rigid core, so the piece holds its shape like a tray and keeps melted snow inside a raised lip. The company also sells flatter All-Weather Floor Mats, which are softer and sit lower in the footwell.
GMC liners come from the GM Accessories program, the same catalog a dealer uses to add a bed liner or running boards. They are molded for the truck, carry the GMC logo and are sold by row, so a first-row set covers only the driver and front passenger. That is the first practical difference: one WeatherTech box can cover both rows, while the GMC route usually means two orders.
The second difference is where you can buy them. WeatherTech lists dozens of Sierra part numbers on Amazon with model years in the title. GM accessory liners show up there too, but the listings rarely print the model years, which makes the dealer parts counter the safer place to check fit.
Bench or Buckets: Check the Front Seat First
The Sierra 1500 does not have one front floor. GMC’s Sierra 1500 page lists a 40/20/40 front bench with under-seat storage on the Pro trim, while higher trims list bucket seats with the MultiPro center console. A liner shaped around a console will not lie flat on a bench-seat truck, and the reverse is just as true.
The rear row has its own variables. Some crew cabs carry a storage bin under the rear seat, and some do not, and both brands cut the second-row piece to suit. Look under your back seat before you order, and note whether your truck has a floor shifter for the transfer case.
Once you know those three things (front seat type, rear storage and shifter), matching a part number becomes quick. If you are still choosing between several brands, our GMC Sierra floor mat roundup covers more sets for this truck.
WeatherTech vs GMC Floor Mats: Three Sets Reviewed
Two of these are WeatherTech products for the 2019-on Sierra 1500 and one is the GMC-logo liner that Amazon carries. Confirm year, cab, seat layout and rear storage on Amazon or with a GMC parts counter before buying, because no single listing fits every Sierra.
WeatherTech FloorLiner 461436-1-2: 1st and 2nd Row HDTE Liners for the 2019-2025 GMC Sierra 1500

- Listed for 2019-2025 GMC Sierra 1500
- Front and second-row liners in one set
- Rigid HDTE core with surface friction
- Channels drain to a lower reservoir
This is WeatherTech’s FloorLiner set for the current-generation Sierra, sold under part number 461436-1-2 in grey. The Amazon listing names the 2019-2025 GMC Sierra 1500 along with the Silverado 1500 and the 2020-2025 Sierra and Silverado heavy-duty trucks, and the set covers both the front and second rows. WeatherTech also sells the same set in black.
WeatherTech builds the FloorLiner from a High-Density Tri-Extruded material, or HDTE. The core is rigid, so the liner keeps its tray shape, while the outer faces add grip against the carpet and a textured feel on top. Molded channels carry water and grit to a lower reservoir and then break up the flow, so slush does not slosh toward the door when you brake. WeatherTech says the liner is designed and made with American-made tooling in the USA.
The bullets do not spell out the front seat layout, and WeatherTech sells separate FloorLiners for 40/20/40 bench trucks and for rear under-seat storage, so match the part number to your cab before ordering. The stiff tray is easy to lift out and hose off. Drivers who want a softer surface or a GMC logo on the floor will prefer the GM liner below.
View WeatherTech FloorLiner 461436-1-2 on Amazon

GM Accessories 84185474: First-Row Premium All-Weather Liners in Jet Black with GMC Logo

- Genuine GM accessory with GMC logo
- First row, for models with a center console
- Deep molded grooves trap snow and water
- Raised sides act as a moisture barrier
This is the GMC-branded liner that Amazon US carries from the GM Accessories catalog, part number 84185474. It is a first-row set in jet black with the GMC logo molded in, built for trucks with a center console between bucket seats. It covers the driver and front passenger only, so a crew cab needs a separate second-row liner to protect the back floor.
The listing describes deep-patterned, molded grooves that trap snow, water and debris so they are easy to dump out. Custom-shaped raised sides extend coverage up the footwell and work as a moisture barrier against mud and slush. GM also says the liners can hide existing wear on the carpet and help protect it from more. The result looks like part of the original interior rather than an add-on.
Fitment needs the most care with this one. The Amazon bullets do not list model years, and GM parts sellers catalog this number for earlier Sierra trucks, while GM’s dealer catalog shows newer liner numbers for the 2019-on body. Give your VIN to a GMC parts counter and confirm the number before ordering, or ask them for the current part for your truck.
View GM Accessories 84185474 on Amazon
WeatherTech All-Weather Floor Mats W489CO-W490CO: TPE Mats for the 2019-2026 GMC Sierra 1500

- Listed for 2019-2026 GMC Sierra 1500
- 1st and 2nd row mats in cocoa
- Flexible, odorless TPE compound
- Sculpted channels hold water, salt and sand
WeatherTech’s All-Weather Floor Mats are the flatter, softer alternative to the FloorLiner, and this pair, W489CO and W490CO, covers the first and second rows in cocoa. The listing names the 2019-2026 Sierra 1500 and Silverado 1500, the 2022 Sierra 1500 Limited and the 2020-2025 Sierra heavy-duty trucks. Cocoa suits brown and tan interiors that would make a black liner stand out.
These are mats rather than liners. They lie flatter on the carpet and do not climb as far up the sides of the footwell, so they hold less runoff than the tray-style FloorLiner. In return, they are flexible and quieter underfoot. Deeply sculpted channels are meant to trap water, road salt, mud and sand, and WeatherTech makes them from a rubber-like thermoplastic elastomer it describes as virtually odorless, latex-free and free of PVC, cadmium and lead.
They are a sensible pick for a truck that sees light winter duty or a mostly dry commute. For a work truck that tracks in deep snow every day, the higher walls of a liner will protect more carpet. As with any Sierra set, confirm your cab, seat layout and rear storage on Amazon before ordering.
View WeatherTech All-Weather Floor Mats on Amazon

The Two Brands Point by Point
This table compares the WeatherTech FloorLiner with the GMC accessory liner, using only what each listing and maker states.
| Point | WeatherTech FloorLiner | GMC accessory liner |
|---|---|---|
| Rows in the box | 1st and 2nd row | 1st row only; 2nd row sold separately |
| Model years on the listing | 2019-2025 Sierra 1500 | Not printed; check the GM number by VIN |
| Material | HDTE with a rigid core | Molded all-weather material, high-friction backing |
| Mess control | Channels to a lower reservoir, raised edges | Deep molded grooves, raised sides |
| Branding | None on the liner | GMC logo |
| Seat layout | Separate part numbers for bench and console trucks | This listing is for models with a center console |
Read the table as two different priorities. WeatherTech gives you clearer fitment data and full-cab coverage in one purchase. The GMC liner gives you a factory look and a softer feel underfoot, with more homework on fit.
Feel underfoot and noise
The rigid FloorLiner keeps its shape out of the truck, which makes it easy to carry to a hose and tip out. The tradeoff is a firmer surface that some drivers find slick with wet boots. GM’s liner is more flexible, sits closer to the carpet and tends to feel like part of the original interior.

Coverage at the edges
Both brands mold the liner up the sides of the footwell. WeatherTech’s listing stresses the lower reservoir that holds runoff away from your feet, while GM describes raised sides that act as a moisture barrier. On a truck that sees lots of slush, the height of that lip near the door sill decides whether salty water stays on the liner or ends up on the carpet.
Salt and Slush in a West Michigan Pickup
A full-size pickup cab takes in a lot of winter. Boots carry packed snow, it melts on the heater, and the brine soaks into carpet fibers if nothing stops it. Over a season, that salt leaves white crust on the carpet and can wick toward the seat brackets and wiring that run under the floor.
Whichever brand you choose, take the liners out every few weeks during salt season, rinse them, and let the carpet dry before they go back in. Our winter car maintenance checklist folds that job into the rest of your cold-weather routine.

Liners are only one piece of a winter kit. For other trucks and cars, our guide to all weather floor mats for snow and salt explains custom versus trim-to-fit designs, and our winter car accessories list covers scrapers, brushes and the rest of the gear worth keeping behind the seat.
Wet Carpet That Liners Don’t Explain
A good liner holds what you track in. It cannot stop water that comes from below or behind the dash. If the carpet under the passenger liner stays damp in dry weather, or you notice a sweet smell or fogged windows, the source is usually a blocked A/C drain, a heater core leak or a failed seal, as explained in our post on water on the passenger side floor.

Don’t let it sit. The EPA’s mold cleanup guidance says to fix water problems quickly and dry things completely, and notes that moldy carpet may need replacing. A heater core leak also drains coolant, so our team handles car heater repair in Grand Rapids and can trace where the water is coming from.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Are GMC factory liners made by WeatherTech?
No. GMC liners are sold through the GM Accessories catalog and carry the GMC logo, while WeatherTech sells its own FloorLiner and All-Weather Floor Mat lines. The two are designed and sold separately, so part numbers do not cross over.
Do GMC liners cover the second row?
Only if you buy the second-row piece. GM sells its premium all-weather liners by row, so the first-row set covers the driver and front passenger. WeatherTech’s FloorLiner listing for the Sierra includes both rows in one order.
Will a bench-seat liner fit a Sierra with a center console?
No. The front floor differs between the 40/20/40 bench and the bucket seats with a console, and both brands mold separate liners for each. Check your seat layout, rear under-seat storage and shifter before ordering.
How do I confirm a GMC liner fits my truck?
Give your VIN to a GMC dealer’s parts counter and ask them to match the accessory part number. The Amazon listings for GM liners often leave out model years, so a VIN check is the reliable step.
Carpet still soaked even with new liners in place? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, or ask for a leak and heater check on our contact page.
Busy until after we close? Our after-hours drop-off at 456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, lets you leave the truck on your way home.
