456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

Explorer Floor Liners Compared: WeatherTech vs Smartliner, Plus Husky

weathertech vs smartliner: rugged vehicle on a snowy urban street in a black and white photograph

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

Shoppers who have already decided on molded liners usually land on the weathertech vs smartliner question next. One brand is the familiar name with a higher price, the other sells a very similar shape for less. Both promise to keep Michigan slush, sand and salt water off the carpet, so the useful differences sit in the material, the fit years and the way each set holds a puddle.

To keep the comparison fair, every set here fits the same SUV: the 2020-2024 Ford Explorer, front and second row. We added the Husky Liners Weatherbeater for the same rows as a third option, since many buyers weigh all three. All specs come from the Amazon US listings and the makers’ own pages.

Quick answer

Should an Explorer owner buy WeatherTech or Smartliner liners?

Pick WeatherTech if you want a rigid, USA-made HDTE liner with molded fluid channels and a deep reservoir. Pick Smartliner if you prefer a lighter, more flexible polyethylene-rubber blend at a lower cost. Both cover the front and second row; check the exact Explorer years on each listing first.

Our Quick Picks

One WeatherTech set and one Smartliner set for the front and second row of the Ford Explorer, plus a Husky Weatherbeater set for the same rows, all reviewed in full below.

WeatherTech FloorLiner 441575-1-2 product photo
Rigid liner pick

WeatherTech FloorLiner 441575-1-2

2020-2021 Explorer, 1st and 2nd row, HDTE

Stiff, USA-made liners with molded channels that move slush away from your feet.

SuitsHeavy slush, long winter commutes, 2020-2021 owners
View on Amazon →
Smartliner 2 Row Set product photo
Lower-cost pick

Smartliner 2 Row Set

2020-2023 Explorer, 2 rows, rubber-polyethylene blend

Custom-fit liners with a raised lip in a lighter, more flexible material.

SuitsDaily drivers, budget-minded families, 2020-2023 owners
View on Amazon →
Husky Weatherbeater 99321 product photo
Widest years pick

Husky Weatherbeater 99321

2020-2027 Explorer, front and 2nd row, 4 pc

Softer liners with grip nibs that cover every Explorer year in our range.

Suits2024 and newer owners, kids, pets, work boots
View on Amazon →

Same SUV, Three Liner Sets

A molded liner is not a flat rubber mat. It is formed to the floor pan of one vehicle, with walls that climb the sill, the center tunnel and the footwell edges. That raised edge is what keeps a boot full of melting snow from spilling over onto the carpet, where it soaks into the padding and stays damp for days.

WeatherTech, Smartliner and Husky all scan the vehicle to make their molds, so the outlines look alike in photos. The materials are where they part ways. WeatherTech uses a stiff tri-extruded sheet, Smartliner uses a semi-flexible blend of rubber and polyethylene, and Husky uses a softer compound it calls ProGard.

The Explorer adds one wrinkle. Ford sells it with a second-row bench or with captain’s chairs, plus regular, ST and Hybrid versions, and liner makers sometimes split part numbers along those lines. Read the fitment line on each listing and use Amazon’s vehicle check before you order.

WeatherTech vs Smartliner Fit Years and Materials

The table lists what each listing states for the Explorer. Where a listing says nothing, we leave the cell plain rather than guess.

PointWeatherTech 441575-1-2Smartliner 2 Row SetHusky Weatherbeater 99321
Explorer years listed2020-2021, including ST and Hybrid2020-20232020-2027
Rows covered1st and 2nd row1st and 2nd rowFront and 2nd row, 4 pieces
MaterialHDTE, rigid coreRecyclable plastic-rubber and polyethylene blendProGard formula, soft underfoot
Liquid controlChannels to a lower reservoirRaised lipFormFit Edge
Where madeUSA, American made toolingChina, India or Thailand (maker FAQ)Not stated in the listing
WeatherTech vs Smartliner, plus Husky, on the 2020-2024 Ford Explorer listings

The years matter most. The WeatherTech set reviewed here stops at 2021, so owners of a 2022 to 2024 Explorer need WeatherTech part 4417161-4415752 instead, which we cover in our SUV floor mat guide. The Smartliner set runs through 2023, and the Husky set covers every year in our range.

WeatherTech vs Smartliner vs Husky: The Explorer Sets Reviewed

Each set below covers the front and second row of the 2020-2024 Explorer, within the years its listing names. Confirm your model year, trim and second-row seating on Amazon before buying, since no single listing fits every Explorer.

WeatherTech FloorLiner 441575-1-2: 1st and 2nd Row HDTE Liners for the 2020-2021 Ford Explorer

WeatherTech FloorLiner 441575-1-2 product photo
Key features
  • Fits select 2020-2021 Explorer, ST and Hybrid
  • Covers the 1st and 2nd row, black
  • Rigid High-Density Tri-Extruded (HDTE) core
  • Channels lead fluids to a lower reservoir

The WeatherTech FloorLiner 441575-1-2 is a two-row set for the Ford Explorer, covering the driver and front passenger footwells plus the second row. The listing names select 2020 and 2021 Explorer models, including the ST and the Explorer Hybrid. WeatherTech asks buyers to confirm fitment for their year, make and model with Amazon’s vehicle check before ordering, which matters here because Explorer seating and trim options vary.

The liners are made from WeatherTech’s patented High-Density Tri-Extruded material, which pairs a rigid core for strength with a surface that grips the carpet underneath and has a textured feel on top. Molded channels carry water and grit toward a lower reservoir, then keep it from sloshing around as you drive. WeatherTech says the FloorLiner is designed, engineered and made in the USA with American made tooling.

That stiff build suits Michigan winters, when melting snow and salt water collect in the footwell every day. A rigid liner keeps its walls upright and is easy to lift out and dump without spilling. The tradeoff is a harder feel than a soft rubber mat. Owners of a 2022 or later Explorer should look at WeatherTech part 4417161-4415752 instead, since this set stops at 2021.

View WeatherTech FloorLiner 441575-1-2 on Amazon

aerial view of Gwangju

SMARTLINER All Weather Custom Fit: 2 Row Floor Liner Set for the 2020-2023 Ford Explorer

Smartliner 2 Row Set product photo
Key features
  • Fits the 2020-2023 Ford Explorer
  • Raised lip, shaped from vehicle scans
  • Recyclable plastic-rubber and polyethylene blend
  • Odorless, hoses off or wipes clean

The SMARTLINER All Weather Custom Fit set covers two rows of the Ford Explorer, and the listing states a fit for the 2020 through 2023 model years. That gives it a wider year range than the WeatherTech set above, which helps owners of a 2022 or 2023 Explorer who want both rows from one listing. Confirm your year, trim and second-row seating on Amazon before buying, since a fit line is not a promise for every configuration.

Smartliner shapes each liner with vehicle scanning and adds a raised lip around the edge to keep snow, mud, sand and salt water off the carpet. The material is a fully recyclable blend of plastic, rubber and polyethylene, and the listing describes it as completely odorless. The surface is textured to resist slipping, and the set cleans with a hose or a damp cloth and mild soap.

On Smartliner’s own help pages, the company says its liners are made in China, India and Thailand and carry a Limited Lifetime Warranty against defects. The semi-flexible blend lies flat and feels a little softer than a rigid liner. It does not describe a fluid reservoir like WeatherTech’s, so empty it more often during a heavy thaw.

View Smartliner 2 Row Set on Amazon

Husky Liners Weatherbeater 99321: Front and 2nd Row Floor Mats for the 2020-2027 Ford Explorer

Husky Weatherbeater 99321 product photo
Key features
  • Fits the 2020-2027 Ford Explorer
  • Front and 2nd row, 4 pieces
  • Soft ProGard formula, resists cracking and curling
  • StayPut nibs and laser-measured FormFit Edge

The Husky Liners Weatherbeater 99321 is a four-piece set covering the front row and the second row of the Ford Explorer. Its listing names the 2020 through 2027 model years, so it is the only set in this comparison that clearly reaches a 2024 Explorer. We include it because many shoppers comparing WeatherTech and Smartliner also look at Husky. As with any liner, confirm your model year and seating layout on Amazon before you order.

Husky makes the Weatherbeater from its ProGard formula, which the company describes as soft underfoot yet resistant to cracking, curling and wear. The laser-measured FormFit Edge follows the contours of the floor, and hundreds of StayPut nibs on the back grip the carpet so the liner does not slide. For the Explorer set, Husky lists a material with no latex, PVC, cadmium or lead.

Mud, water and road grime release quickly, so the liners can be popped out and rinsed clean on a mild day. The softer feel suits families with young kids or dogs, and drivers who climb in with muddy boots. It does not list a deep reservoir like WeatherTech’s, so a soft liner may need emptying sooner when slush piles up.

View Husky Weatherbeater 99321 on Amazon

snow-covered urban street with traffic lights and a lone pedestrian

Stiff, Flexible or Soft: How the Materials Behave

Holding slush and salt water

A West Michigan winter puts more water on a driver’s floor than most summers ever do. Snow packs into boot treads, melts in the warm cabin and carries road salt with it. WeatherTech’s rigid core lets it hold molded channels that lead that water down to a lower reservoir, away from your heel, which helps on long commutes when the puddle never really dries.

Smartliner relies on a raised lip around the edge rather than describing a reservoir. Husky describes an edge-to-edge FormFit design. Either works as long as you empty the liner before the water reaches the rim, and dumping a full liner on a cold morning is easier with a stiff one that keeps its shape.

close-up of professional camera lens filters laid out on a dark surface

Feel underfoot and in the cold

Rigid liners hold their walls well but can feel hard and, to some owners, slick when wet. Softer liners grip shoes better and lie flatter against the carpet, at the cost of a little wall stiffness. Smartliner sits between the two, and its maker says its liners are about a quarter to half an inch thick depending on the spot.

Whatever you buy, keep the driver’s liner hooked to the factory retention posts and never stack it on top of another mat. A loose or doubled mat can slide forward and crowd the pedals, which is a real safety issue, not a comfort one.

Cleaning off the salt

Dried road salt leaves a white crust that tracks back onto the carpet if it stays on the liner. All three sets come out and rinse with a hose. Smartliner’s help center suggests warm water, a soft brush and mild dish soap, warns against chemical cleaners and asks that the liner be fully dry before it goes back in. That is sound advice for any brand.

Dry the carpet underneath too, at least a few times a season. Water that sneaks past the edge sits under the liner where you cannot see it. Our Michigan winter car maintenance checklist folds that into a simple cold-season routine with the other jobs that keep salt from doing damage.

Matching a Set to Your Explorer

Start with your model year, then think about how you use the SUV through the winter.

Your situationBetter fitWhy
2020 or 2021 Explorer, ST or Hybrid, heavy slushWeatherTech 441575-1-2Rigid walls, channels and a lower reservoir
2020-2023 Explorer, lower spendSmartliner 2 Row SetCustom fit with a raised lip in a lighter blend
2024 Explorer or newerHusky Weatherbeater 99321Listing covers 2020-2027
Kids, dogs or muddy work bootsHusky Weatherbeater 99321Soft surface with StayPut nibs
You care where it is madeWeatherTech 441575-1-2Made in the USA per the listing
WeatherTech vs Smartliner vs Husky matched to Explorer owners

For most families the gap between these sets is smaller than the marketing suggests. Any of them beats carpet mats in a salty winter. If you are still weighing other brands or a trim-to-fit option, our all weather floor mats for snow and salt roundup covers more styles and vehicles.

person walks past a brick building during a snowstorm in an urban setting

Liners also pair well with the rest of a winter kit. A good snow brush, an ice scraper and a cargo liner all keep the cabin cleaner. Our list of winter car accessories gathers those in one place, and our WeatherTech vs Husky comparison runs the two other brands head to head on a Ram pickup.

Wet Carpet Under Good Liners

Sometimes the floor stays soaked no matter which liner you fit. If the carpet is wet on the passenger side and nobody tracked snow in, the water is probably coming from the vehicle itself. A clogged A/C drain, a leaking heater core or a failed seal can all put water on the floor from underneath or behind the dash.

tranquil urban scene with heavy snowfall

Our guide to water on the passenger side floor walks through those causes and the clues for each, like a sweet smell or fogged glass. When the heater or A/C system is the source, our team handles car heater repair in Grand Rapids and can trace the leak before the carpet padding starts to smell.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Smartliner as good as WeatherTech?

Both are custom molded from vehicle scans and cover the same rows. WeatherTech uses a stiffer HDTE material with fluid channels and is made in the USA. Smartliner uses a lighter, more flexible blend and costs less. For everyday winter use, either keeps the carpet dry when it fits your exact vehicle.

Which WeatherTech set fits a 2022 to 2024 Ford Explorer?

The 441575-1-2 set reviewed here lists 2020 and 2021 models. For 2022 and later Explorers, WeatherTech lists part 4417161-4415752 for the first and second row. Match your Explorer’s year and trim on Amazon before you order.

Where are Smartliner liners made?

Smartliner’s own help center says its liners are made in China, India and Thailand, with customer service based in Florida. It also lists a Limited Lifetime Warranty against defects in material or workmanship.

Can I put a liner on top of my factory carpet mat?

No. Take the carpet mat out first and secure the liner to the factory retention hooks. Stacking mats lets the top one slide toward the pedals, which can interfere with braking or acceleration.

Carpet still damp after a week of dry weather? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, or ask us to check for a cabin leak through our contact page.

Busy during shop hours? Our after-hours drop-off at 456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, lets you leave the SUV whenever your day allows.