456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

Commuter, Upgrade or Tow Rig? Power Stop Z17 vs Z23 vs Z36 on the F-150

power stop z17 vs z23 vs z36: busy workshop interior featuring a shoe polishing machine and various tools and supplies

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

Once you settle on Power Stop for a brake job, the next screen asks you to choose a line, and the three that show up most are numbered like a code you are supposed to know already. The power stop z17 vs z23 vs z36 question is really about how you use the vehicle: plain commuting, commuting with a bit more bite, or pulling and carrying weight on a regular basis.

To compare like with like, we picked the front set from each line for one truck that has all three listed on Amazon: the 2015-2020 Ford F-150. All three carry the same 2087 part suffix, so the pad shape is identical and the only differences are compound, shims and what comes in the box. If you are still weighing other brands, our roundup of brake pads for daily driving covers a wider field.

Quick answer

Which Power Stop pad line suits a 2015-2020 F-150?

Pick Z17 if the truck mostly commutes empty and you want a stock-style ceramic replacement. Choose Z23 when you want a little more stopping power for daily use without a truck-specific compound. Go with Z36 if you tow, haul heavy loads, run bigger tires or drive steep grades often.

Our Quick Picks

The front set from each of the three Power Stop lines, all in the same 2087 shape listed for the 2015-2020 Ford F-150, each reviewed in full below.

Power Stop Z17 17-2087 product photo
Daily commuter pick

Power Stop Z17 17-2087

Ceramic, front, 2087 shape

A factory-style ceramic set for a truck that mostly runs empty.

SuitsCommuting F-150s, budget refreshes
View on Amazon →
Power Stop Z23 Z23-2087 product photo
Daily upgrade pick

Power Stop Z23 Z23-2087

Carbon-fiber ceramic, front, 2087

More bite than the stock line while staying quiet and clean.

SuitsDaily drivers who want firmer stops
View on Amazon →
Power Stop Z36 Z36-2087 product photo
Towing and hauling pick

Power Stop Z36 Z36-2087

Truck-formula ceramic, front, 2087

The severe-duty line for trailers, heavy beds and long hills.

SuitsF-150s that tow, plow or haul
View on Amazon →

How Power Stop Separates the Three Lines

Power Stop sells these lines as steps on a ladder rather than rivals. Z17 is labeled a stock replacement for daily drivers, built from a ceramic formula with a thermally scorched surface that the maker says speeds up break-in. It is the closest thing in the catalog to the pad the truck left the factory with.

Z23, sold as Evolution Sport, moves to a carbon-fiber ceramic mix. Power Stop pitches it as an upgrade for everyday cars, trucks and SUVs that adds braking power without making the pedal grabby or the wheels dirty. Z36, the Truck and Tow line, uses a carbon-fiber ceramic compound strengthened for what the maker calls severe-duty stopping, and its Z36 product page lists towing, hauling, big tire upgrades, mountain driving and off-road use as its targets.

All three are ceramic-family pads, not semi-metallic, which is why none of them should coat your wheels in black dust the way some heavy-duty truck pads do. Modern pad formulas have also changed for environmental reasons. Under the EPA Copper-Free Brake Initiative, makers agreed to cut copper in brake pads to under 5 percent by weight by 2021 and 0.5 percent by 2025, along with limits on lead, mercury and other metals.

That shared starting point matters, because it means the gap between the lines is narrower than the price ladder suggests. You are choosing how much heat the pad is built to handle and how firm the bite feels, not switching between completely different technologies.

Z17, Z23 and Z36 Side by Side on the F-150

The details below come from the three Amazon US listings and Power Stop’s own line pages. Where neither source says something, the table leaves it out rather than filling the gap with a guess.

PointZ17 (17-2087)Z23 (Z23-2087)Z36 (Z36-2087)
Maker’s role for itStock replacement for daily driversUpgrade for daily driversSevere duty for trucks and SUVs
CompoundLow-dust ceramicCarbon-fiber ceramicCarbon-fiber ceramic, truck formula
ShimsDual-layer rubberizedDual-layer rubberizedStainless steel, for heat transfer
Pad faceThermal scorched, chamfered, slottedChamfered and slottedChamfered and slotted
In the boxPads and stainless hardwarePads, hardware, brake lubricantPads, hardware, brake lubricant
Fade resistanceNot singled outListed as fade resistantListed for towing and grade work
Power Stop Z17, Z23 and Z36 front pads for the 2015-2020 Ford F-150, compared from Amazon US listings and Power Stop line pages

The shim change on Z36 is the most telling detail. Rubberized shims are mainly there to soak up vibration and keep stops quiet, while the stainless-steel shims on the truck line are meant to move heat away from the backing plate. That trade suits a truck coming down a long hill with a trailer behind it more than one idling through school pickup.

Power Stop Z17 vs Z23 vs Z36: The Three F-150 Sets in Detail

Each set below is a front axle listing that names the F-150 alongside the Expedition and Lincoln Navigator. Ford fitted more than one front brake size across these model years, so enter your year, cab, drivetrain and brake package in Amazon’s fit checker before ordering any of them.

Power Stop Z17 17-2087: Stock Replacement Ceramic Front Pads with Hardware for F-150

Power Stop Z17 17-2087 product photo
Key features
  • Low-dust ceramic, stock replacement line
  • Thermal scorched for a quicker break-in
  • Chamfered, slotted, dual-layer rubber shims
  • Stainless installation hardware included

Part 17-2087 is the front set from Power Stop’s Z17 line, which the company describes as a stock replacement for daily drivers. The Amazon listing names the 2010 to 2020 Ford F-150 plus the Expedition and Lincoln Navigator, and it asks buyers to confirm fit through the Amazon fit bar or the product description. Ford used different front brake sizes on some trims in that span, so check your year, cab and brake package before you order.

The friction material is a low-dust ceramic, and the pad face is thermally scorched at the factory, a treatment Power Stop says helps the pads seat quickly against the rotors. Chamfered ends and a center slot are there to reduce squeal, and dual-layer rubberized shims add a second line of defense against noise. Power Stop also points to a powder-coated backing plate that resists rust and a stainless hardware kit in the box.

This is the set to choose when the truck spends its life commuting, running errands and carrying the odd load of mulch. It aims to feel like the original pads, nothing firmer. The box has no brake lubricant listed, so pick up a brake-rated grease for the slide pins. If you tow regularly, look at one of the upgrade lines instead.

View Power Stop Z17 17-2087 on Amazon

scenic dirt path through fields under dramatic clouds

Power Stop Z23 Z23-2087: Evolution Sport Carbon-Fiber Ceramic Front Pads for F-150

Power Stop Z23 Z23-2087 product photo
Key features
  • Carbon-fiber ceramic upgrade compound
  • Low-dust formula, listed as fade resistant
  • Rubberized shims, chamfered and slotted
  • Hardware and brake lubricant in the box

Z23-2087 is the Evolution Sport front set for the same trucks as the Z17 part above: the 2010 to 2020 F-150, the Expedition and the Navigator, according to the Amazon listing. Power Stop calls it a direct-fit upgrade for daily driving brake systems, meaning it bolts on without changes. As with any listing that spans this many years, confirm your exact truck in the fit checker before buying, because front brake sizes changed between trims.

The step up from Z17 is the compound. Power Stop adds carbon fiber to its ceramic mix and says the result gives more stopping power than OE replacement pads while staying quiet. The listing also describes a low-dust formula that resists fade, so the pedal should stay consistent through a run of stops. Rubberized shims and chamfered, slotted pads keep the noise control familiar, and the maker’s page lists a high-temperature brake lubricant along with the stainless hardware.

Choose this set if the truck is a daily driver and you want brakes that respond a little more firmly, perhaps with an occasional light trailer. Having the lubricant in the box makes a clean driveway job easier. It is not the truck line, so for heavy or frequent towing the Z36 set below is the closer fit.

View Power Stop Z23 Z23-2087 on Amazon

Power Stop Z36 Z36-2087: Truck and Tow Carbon-Fiber Ceramic Front Pads for F-150

Power Stop Z36 Z36-2087 product photo
Key features
  • Truck and Tow carbon-fiber ceramic
  • Stainless shims for heat dissipation
  • Made for towing, hauling and grades
  • Hardware and brake lubricant included

Z36-2087 is the front set from Power Stop’s Truck and Tow line, listed on Amazon for the 2010 to 2020 F-150, Expedition and Navigator. It is the same listing we covered in our F150 brake pad guide, and it returns here as the heavy-duty step of the Power Stop ladder. Confirm the year, cab and brake package on Amazon before ordering, since not every truck in that range shares this front pad.

Power Stop builds the Z36 compound from carbon-fiber ceramic strengthened for severe-duty stopping, and the listing aims it at trucks, SUVs and 4x4s that tow, haul, climb mountain roads or run lifted suspensions. It says the formula reduces brake fade under that extra stress while staying quiet. The biggest hardware difference is the shim: the maker’s page lists stainless-steel shims chosen for heat dissipation, plus stainless hardware and a high-temperature lubricant.

This set suits a truck that pulls a camper or boat, hauls a loaded bed or pushes a plow through a Michigan winter. Because it is tuned for heat, it can feel firmer than factory pads, so complete the break-in before you hook up a trailer. Owners who never tow will likely be just as well served by Z17 or Z23.

View Power Stop Z36 Z36-2087 on Amazon

milling machine locating in middle of messy shabby workshop with brick walls various tools on tables and piece

Which Set Fits the Way You Use Your Truck

Start with the heaviest job the truck does in a typical month, not the lightest. A pickup that pulls a boat trailer six weekends a summer still needs pads that can cope with that load, even if it spends the rest of the year commuting empty.

How you driveLeaningWhy
Empty commuting, light errandsZ17Stock-style ceramic, quiet shims, simple swap
Daily driving, wants firmer biteZ23Carbon-fiber ceramic aimed at daily upgrades
Regular trailer towingZ36Truck formula and shims built for heat
Bed loads, plow or work gearZ36Maker lists hauling as a core use
Larger aftermarket tiresZ36Big tire upgrades named on the line page
Lowest-cost refresh on an older truckZ17Positioned as the budget-conscious line
Matching Z17, Z23 and Z36 pads to common F-150 driving patterns

In the power stop z17 vs z23 vs z36 decision, the middle ground is where most half-ton owners get stuck. Z23 is a reasonable fit for an F-150 that tows a small utility trailer once in a while, since it gains bite over the stock line without a truck-only compound. If the trailer is heavy or the trips are frequent, Z36 is the safer match, and our guide to choosing brake pads for trucks goes deeper on towing and plow use.

idyllic countryside road winding past a rustic barn with lush green surroundings and distant forested hills

Whichever line you choose, pad life will depend more on your routes and loads than on the letter on the box. Short city trips with lots of stops wear pads far faster than highway miles, and towing speeds that up again. Our article on how long brake pads last explains the factors, and a quick look at the lining during each tire rotation keeps surprises away.

Salt, Slush and Break-In on West Michigan Roads

Around Grand Rapids, the pad compound is seldom the part that gives up first. Brine and slush work into the caliper brackets over the winter, rust swells under the clips and slide pins start to bind, so a perfectly good pad drags or wears at an angle. That is why the hardware in each box is worth fitting rather than tossing in the scrap bin.

Power Stop says all three lines use a powder-coated backing plate meant to resist rust, which helps, but it does nothing for a seized pin. Clean the bracket abutments to bare metal, use a brake-rated lubricant on the pins and contact points, and check that each clip snaps in flat. The Z23 and Z36 boxes include a lubricant; with Z17, buy a tube separately.

modern industrial setting with a large granite cutting machine in action inside a factory

Break-in is the step people skip most, and cold mornings are when it shows. Power Stop’s procedure is five firm stops from 40 mph down to 10 mph without coming to a halt, then five moderate stops from 35 mph down to 5 mph, followed by about five minutes of easy driving to cool off. Don’t sit with your foot hard on the pedal while the rotors are hot, and never cool them with water.

New pads also need a sound rotor surface. If the rotors are near the minimum thickness stamped on them, scored, or pitted from a salty season, swap them along with the pads; our page on picking rotors for an F150 covers the options.

When the Truck Needs More Than Fresh Pads

A new set from any of these lines replaces worn friction material, and that is all it does. It won’t cure a caliper that hangs up, a rotor with uneven thickness or a spongy pedal from moisture-laden fluid. If the truck pulls to one side, the steering wheel shudders when you slow down, or one wheel smells hot after a drive, get the whole corner looked at first.

serene rural scene showing a winding road leading to a red barn under a dramatic sky

Wear warnings vary a lot between vehicles. Many European cars use an electronic pad sensor and a dash message, as our explainer on the Audi brake pad warning light describes, but don’t count on a dash alert in a pickup. A high-pitched squeal on light braking or a grinding sound means the lining is close to finished, so book the work instead of waiting.

If torque specs, caliper bracket bolts or bleeding the system feel outside your comfort zone, hand the job to a shop. We handle pads, rotors, calipers and hardware for foreign and domestic vehicles through our brake repair service in Grand Rapids. Hendrick Hoffman, who runs the shop, holds ASE and State of Michigan certifications that include brakes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Z36 overkill for an F-150 that never tows?

Usually, yes. Power Stop builds Z36 for towing, hauling, big tires and steep grades, so an empty commuter gains little from it. Z17 or Z23 matches that use better, and both come with rubberized shims aimed at quiet stops.

What about Power Stop Z26?

Z26 is Power Stop’s Street Warrior line, which the maker aims at muscle cars, modified cars and other performance vehicles. Its number sits close to Z36, so the two get mixed up in searches. For a half-ton pickup, the realistic choice is Z17, Z23 or Z36.

Can I run Z36 on the front and a different line on the rear?

You can, but matching lines front and rear keeps the brake balance closer to what you expect. If you tow, putting the truck line on both axles makes sense. Rear pads are sold separately, so check the part number for your truck.

Do these pads need a break-in?

Yes. Power Stop describes a series of firm stops from 40 mph and moderate stops from 35 mph without coming to a full halt, then a cool-down drive. Skipping it can leave uneven deposits on the rotors and a vibration you feel through the pedal.

Hearing a squeal from the front of your truck, or just unsure which pads it needs? Reach 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832 between 8am and 5pm, Monday to Friday, or ask for a brake check on our contact page.

If your workday overlaps our hours, bring the truck by 456 Carrier St NE after we close, use the after-hours drop-off with a quick note on what you are hearing, and we will phone you once it has been inspected.