456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

Stuck Filter, Slippery Can: Choosing the Best Oil Filter Pliers

best oil filter pliers: long stretch of highway through countryside with dramatic cloud-filled sky

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

A filter that was spun on by someone with strong hands, then baked through a few thousand miles of heat cycles, rarely comes off with a strap or a bare palm. The best oil filter pliers bite into the can with toothed jaws and give you a long handle to turn it, even when the filter sits behind a crossmember.

Below, we compare pliers with other filter wrenches, explain jaw ranges and review six pairs from small engines to pickups. For a broader look at every style of remover, see our oil filter wrench buying guide.

Quick answer

Which oil filter pliers should a home mechanic buy?

For most cars, a compact slip-joint pair with angled jaws, such as the Lisle 50750 (2-1/4 to 4 inches), reaches filters in tight spots. If you also service a truck or tractor, a two-size set like the Channellock OF-1 covers larger cans. Measure your filter first, because every pair has a fixed range.

Our Quick Picks

Three places to start: a compact pair for tucked car filters, a two-size set that reaches truck filters, and locking jaws for a filter that will not budge. All six pairs are reviewed below.

Lisle 50750 product photo
Compact pick

Lisle 50750

2-1/4 to 4 in, 20-degree jaws

Angled jaws reach filters mounted sideways or behind brackets.

SuitsMost cars and small SUVs
View on Amazon →
Channellock OF-1 product photo
Two-size set

Channellock OF-1

12 in and 15.5 in pliers

A matched pair that steps up from car filters to truck filters.

SuitsGarages with cars and trucks
View on Amazon →
CRAFTSMAN CMMT98303 product photo
Locking grip

CRAFTSMAN CMMT98303

Locking jaws, 2.5 to 4.5 in

Clamps and holds the can so your hands only have to turn.

SuitsStuck or slippery filters
View on Amazon →

Oil Filter Pliers vs Wrench: Which Tool Fits the Job?

A cap wrench is a cup that fits one filter size and turns with a ratchet. A band wrench wraps around the can, and a three-jaw wrench clamps from the end. Pliers grab the side of the can with serrated jaws and use handle length for leverage.

  • Pliers win when a filter is stuck, slippery or crushed, or when you service several vehicles with different filter sizes.
  • A cap wrench wins when there is no room to swing a handle, and it is the right tool for snugging a cartridge housing cap.

The trade-off is that even the best oil filter pliers dent or puncture the can as they grip. That is fine on the way off, but it makes them a removal tool only. New filters go on by hand, following the tightening note printed on the filter or its box.

Choosing Oil Filter Removal Pliers: Range, Jaw Angle and Reach

Start with the diameter of your filter. Measure across the can with a tape or caliper, or read the size from the filter maker’s catalog, then pick oil filter removal pliers whose listed range covers it with a little room on either side. Most car filters fall inside a 2-1/2 to 4 inch range, while diesel pickups and tractors often need something larger.

Next, look at the jaws. Bent jaws reach a filter mounted sideways or above a subframe, while straight jaws give more direct force in open space. Locking pliers clamp at a set width so your hand only has to turn.

Finally, a longer handle gives more turning force but needs more swing room. For a buried filter, a shorter pair or a cap wrench on an extension from your mechanic tool set may do better.

Best Oil Filter Pliers: Six Pairs Reviewed

The six tools below run from a 9-inch pair for small engines to a 6-inch-capacity truck plier. Ranges and materials come from each Amazon listing.

1. Lisle 50750: 2-1/4 to 4 Inch Oil Filter Pliers with 20-Degree Bent Jaws

Lisle 50750 product photo
Key features
  • Range of 2-1/4 to 4 inches
  • Two-position slip-joint handle
  • Jaws bent at a 20-degree angle
  • Sure-grip teeth to resist slipping

The Lisle 50750 is a single pair of oil filter pliers built around a two-position slip-joint handle. Lisle lists an overall range of 2-1/4 to 4 inches and says the two positions give the coverage of three separate conventional filter wrenches, which covers the filter sizes found on most passenger cars and small SUVs.

The jaws are bent at a 20-degree angle, and that angle is the main reason to choose this pair. It lets you approach a filter from the side or from below without the handles hitting an exhaust pipe, a subframe or a splash shield. The jaws carry sure-grip teeth that bite into the can, so an oily or slightly rusty filter is less likely to spin in the tool. Because the pliers are compact, they also fit in a small drawer or an oil change kit.

In use, you set the slip joint to the position that closes the jaws around the can, grip near the base and turn counterclockwise. The teeth will mark or puncture the filter, so this is a removal tool only. Filters larger than 4 inches, such as many diesel truck filters, need a bigger pair like the Lisle 50950 instead.

View Lisle 50750 on Amazon

2. Channellock OF-1: 12 and 15.5 Inch Oil Filter and PVC Pliers Set

Channellock OF-1 product photo
Key features
  • Two pliers: 12 inch and 15.5 inch
  • Fits most car, truck and heavy equipment filters
  • PermaLock fastener at the pivot
  • Made in the USA

The Channellock OF-1 is a two-piece set of oil filter and PVC pliers, one 12 inches long and one 15.5 inches long. Channellock lists the pair as fitting most car, truck and heavy equipment filters, which makes it a practical choice for a household that keeps a sedan, a pickup and perhaps a tractor or generator in the same garage.

Both pliers use Channellock’s PermaLock fastener at the pivot, which the company says eliminates the nut and bolt failure that can loosen a cheaper slip joint over time. The jaws are designed to wrap around round objects, so the same tools also grip PVC pipe, conduit and fittings around the house. The finish is matte and unpolished, and the set is made in the USA.

The 12-inch pliers handle typical passenger-car filters, while the longer 15.5-inch pair gives more reach and leverage on large truck and equipment filters. Long handles do need room to swing, so on a car with a filter buried high in the engine bay, the shorter tool or a cap wrench may be easier. As with any toothed pliers, plan to use them only for removal and fit the new filter by hand.

View Channellock OF-1 on Amazon

winding road seen from the road

3. CRAFTSMAN CMMT98303: Locking Oil Filter Pliers for 2.5 to 4.5 Inch Filters

CRAFTSMAN CMMT98303 product photo
Key features
  • Locking, adjustable jaws
  • Fits filters 2.5 to 4.5 inches (64 to 116 mm)
  • Dipped handles for grip
  • Sized for automotive use

The CRAFTSMAN CMMT98303 takes a different approach from slip-joint pliers. It is a locking pair: you adjust the jaws to the filter and clamp them shut, and the tool holds its grip without you squeezing the handles. CRAFTSMAN lists the adjustable jaws as fitting filters from 2.5 to 4.5 inches in diameter, or 64 to 116 millimeters.

That locking action is useful on a filter that was overtightened or has been on the engine for a long time. Once the jaws are clamped, all of your effort goes into turning instead of holding on, and the tool is less likely to slip off an oily can halfway through a pull. The handles are dipped for comfort and a more secure hold, which helps when your gloves are already slick.

Setting a locking tool takes a few seconds longer than grabbing a slip-joint pair, because you need to adjust the jaw width before you clamp. It is also a removal tool, since the locked jaws will crush the can. If your filter is larger than 4.5 inches, look at a truck-sized pair, and on a cartridge filter housing use the correct cap wrench rather than any pliers.

View CRAFTSMAN CMMT98303 on Amazon

4. WORKPRO Oil Filter Wrench Set: 9 and 12 Inch Pliers with 5-Position Slip Joint

WORKPRO 9 and 12 Inch Set product photo
Key features
  • 9 inch and 12 inch pliers
  • 12 inch fits 2-1/2 to 3-3/4 inches
  • 9 inch fits 1-3/4 to 3 inches
  • Carbon steel, gray phosphate finish

The WORKPRO oil filter wrench set includes two slip-joint pliers, a 9-inch and a 12-inch pair. WORKPRO lists the 12-inch tool as adjusting from 2-1/2 to 3-3/4 inches and the 9-inch tool from 1-3/4 to 3 inches, so between them they cover small filters on motorcycles and mowers as well as common car filters.

Each tool has a five-position slip joint, which lets you set the jaw opening more precisely than a two-position design. The angled gripping teeth are designed to bite in either direction, and WORKPRO says the serrated jaws hold firmly on slippery, oil-covered filters. The bodies are carbon steel with a gray phosphate finish, and the extended handles add reach and leverage for filters in confined spaces.

This set suits someone who changes oil on more than just a car, such as a riding mower, a motorcycle or a small generator, since the 9-inch pair reaches the smaller filters those engines use. The 3-3/4 inch upper limit of the larger tool means it will not fit many truck filters, so measure before you rely on it for a pickup. The teeth will mark the can, so keep these for removal.

View WORKPRO 9 and 12 Inch Set on Amazon

monochrome image of an industrial pressure gauge showing detailed measurements

5. Lisle 50950: 3-5/8 to 6 Inch Oil Filter Pliers for Trucks and Tractors

Lisle 50950 product photo
Key features
  • Range of 3-5/8 to 6 inches
  • Two-position slip-joint handle
  • Sure-grip teeth
  • Cushioned handles

The Lisle 50950 is built for the big filters that car-sized pliers cannot open wide enough to grab. Lisle lists an overall range of 3-5/8 to 6 inches and describes the tool as oil filter pliers for trucks and tractors, which covers many diesel pickups, farm equipment and larger gas engines.

Like the smaller Lisle 50750, it uses a two-position slip-joint handle to give a wide range from one tool. The jaws carry sure-grip teeth that help prevent the can from spinning, which matters on a large filter where there is more surface for oil and road grime to coat. The handles are cushioned, adding comfort when a big filter needs a long, steady pull.

Because the range starts at 3-5/8 inches, this pair is not a fit for most passenger-car filters, so it works best as a second tool beside a smaller set. It is a sensible choice for anyone who maintains a diesel truck or a tractor and has struggled with band wrenches that slip on oily cans. Check your filter’s diameter against the listed range, and plan to use the pliers for removal only, since the teeth will dent the can.

View Lisle 50950 on Amazon

6. Channellock 209: 9 Inch Oil Filter and PVC Slip-Joint Pliers

Channellock 209 product photo
Key features
  • 9-inch slip-joint pliers
  • Fits common car and small engine filters
  • PermaLock fastener
  • Made in the USA, blue grips

The Channellock 209 is a 9-inch oil filter and PVC plier, the smallest pair in this list. Channellock describes it as fitting most common car and small engine filters, so it suits compact cars, riding mowers, generators and similar equipment where a long handle would only get in the way.

It uses the same PermaLock fastener found on Channellock’s larger filter pliers, which the company says prevents the pivot nut and bolt from failing. The handles carry the brand’s blue grips for comfort and control, and the jaws are shaped to wrap around round parts, so the tool also works on PVC pipe, conduit and fittings. The pliers are made in the USA.

The short length is both the strength and the limit of this tool. It slips into tight engine bays and small equipment housings easily, but it gives less leverage than a 12-inch or 15-inch pair, so a filter that was badly overtightened may call for something longer. Larger truck filters are beyond its range. Treat it as a handy everyday pair for small filters, use it for removal only, and keep a bigger tool nearby for heavier jobs.

View Channellock 209 on Amazon

Jaw Ranges at a Glance

Use the listed range to narrow down the best oil filter pliers for your garage, then confirm your filter size before you order.

PliersListed range or fitGrip styleGood match for
Lisle 507502-1/4 to 4 inTwo-position slip joint, 20-degree bent jawsCars and small SUVs with tucked filters
Channellock OF-112 in and 15.5 in pair, car to heavy equipmentSlip joint, PermaLock pivotMixed garages with cars and trucks
CRAFTSMAN CMMT983032.5 to 4.5 inLocking jawsStuck or slippery filters
WORKPRO 9 in and 12 in set1-3/4 to 3 in and 2-1/2 to 3-3/4 inFive-position slip jointMotorcycles, mowers and cars
Lisle 509503-5/8 to 6 inTwo-position slip jointDiesel pickups, trucks and tractors
Channellock 209Common car and small engine filtersSlip joint, 9 inSmall engines and compact cars
Oil filter pliers compared by listed jaw range and grip style

In West Michigan, winter road salt can rust the outside of a filter can, especially on trucks with low-mounted filters. Rust makes a band wrench slip, which is one reason toothed pliers earn a spot in a Michigan toolbox.

aerial shot of a road dividing plowed and green fields

How to Use Oil Filter Pliers Safely

Get the car up safely before you reach under it. Lift with a jack at the points in your owner’s manual, then set it on jack stands; our floor jack value guide covers jacks that suit a home garage. Wear eye protection and gloves, and let a hot engine cool, because oil and the filter can stay hot for a while after driving.

  1. Drain first: pull the drain plug and let the oil empty into a pan.
  2. Set the jaws: pick the slip-joint position where the jaws close firmly on the can.
  3. Grip low: clamp near the base of the can, where it is stiffer, rather than the thin middle.
  4. Turn counterclockwise: viewed from the filter end, pull in short arcs and re-grip as needed.
  5. Check the gasket: make sure the old rubber seal came off with the filter before fitting the new one by hand.

Keep a wide pan under the filter; our oil drain pan guide lists pans with room for the filter too. The EPA advises draining used filters and taking them, along with the oil, to a collection center; its page on managing and recycling used oil explains why.

aerial view of a highway cutting through lush forests

If you rotate tires during the same visit, an impact wrench and the sockets in our impact socket set guide make quick work of the lug nuts while the car is already up.

When the Filter Fights Back, Call Us

If the can tears, the threads feel cross-threaded, or the mounting stud turns with the filter, stop. Even the best oil filter pliers cannot fix that, and forcing it can damage the filter adapter on the engine.

Our oil change service in Creston handles stubborn filters as part of the job. If you would rather hand over the whole service schedule, our factory scheduled maintenance in Grand Rapids follows the items your owner’s manual lists for your mileage.

curving road through a picturesque alpine landscape with snow-capped peaks

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I install a new oil filter with pliers?

No. Pliers can dent the new can or overtighten it, which makes the next change harder. Oil the new gasket lightly and tighten by hand as the filter’s instructions describe.

What are the best oil filter wrench pliers for trucks?

Look for a range that goes past 4-1/2 inches. The Lisle 50950 is listed at 3-5/8 to 6 inches, and the 15.5-inch pliers in the Channellock OF-1 set are listed for truck and heavy equipment filters. Measure your filter to be sure.

Why do my pliers keep slipping on the filter?

Usually the jaws are on the wrong slip-joint position or gripping the soft middle of the can. Wipe the oil off, move the grip toward the base and choose the position where the jaws close fully on the can.

Do oil filter pliers work on cartridge filters?

Not on the housing cap. Many newer engines use a cartridge element inside a plastic or aluminum housing, and that cap needs the correct socket-style cap wrench. Pliers can crack the plastic.

Would you rather skip the crawl under the car? Give 456 AutoFix a call at 616-279-3832 any weekday from 8am to 5pm, or send us a note through the contact page and we will set up a time.

If your workday runs past our hours, the after-hours drop-off is there for you. Bring the vehicle to 456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505, and we will get to it during business hours.