As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
Ask a room of truck owners about front pads and two upgrade brands come up fast. The power stop vs hawk debate usually gets framed as quiet ceramic against aggressive bite, and there is some truth in that, but both companies sell more than one compound for the same pickup, so the brand name alone tells you less than the line printed on the box.
To keep things fair, every pad here fits one truck and one axle: the front brakes of the 2016 to 2023 Toyota Tacoma, the third-generation truck. Those pickups use drum brakes at the back, so the front pads do most of the stopping and are the part most owners replace. For a broader look at compounds first, our guide to the best brake pads for daily driving covers the basics.
Quick answer
Which front pad should a 2016-2023 Tacoma get, Power Stop or Hawk?
Pick the Power Stop Z23-976 for a quiet, low-dust ceramic set that ships with hardware. Pick Hawk’s LTS HB490Y.665 if the truck carries weight or tows and you want stronger bite from a pad made for trucks. Hawk’s HPS HB490F.665 suits owners who want firm street feel without a truck-specific compound.
Our Quick Picks
One Power Stop set and two Hawk compounds, all front pads for the 2016-2023 Toyota Tacoma, with Hawk's HPS included as a closely related third pick. Each is reviewed in full below.

Power Stop Z23-976
Quiet, clean ceramic upgrade that arrives with new clips for the job.

Hawk LTS HB490Y.665
Hawk's truck compound, aimed at loaded pickups and moderate towing.

Hawk HPS HB490F.665
Hawk's classic street pad for a sharper pedal on an unloaded truck.
Two Upgrade Brands With Different Habits
Power Stop built its name on boxed upgrade kits, and most of its pads use a carbon-fiber ceramic friction mix. The company sorts them by job: Z17 for straight replacement, Z23 for daily driving with a bit more bite, and Z36 for trucks that tow. Nearly every listing in those lines includes the installation hardware, which keeps a home brake job to one order.
Hawk Performance comes from the racing side and is now a brand of Carlisle Brake & Friction. It sells one pad shape in several compounds, each with its own suffix letter. On the Tacoma front axle, the shape is HB490 with a .665 thickness, and the letter after it tells you the compound: Y for LTS, F for HPS, B for HPS 5.0 and so on.
So the real choice is not brand against brand. It is one Power Stop line against one or two Hawk compounds, and that is how we have set up the picks below.
What a Tacoma Front Axle Asks of a Pad
A Tacoma is a midsize truck, but many of them do full-size work. Owners add steel bumpers, roof racks, bed campers and bigger all-terrain tires, then pull a small boat or utility trailer on weekends. Every one of those changes adds weight or rotating mass, and the front pads absorb most of the extra heat.
That is why friction type matters more here than on a commuter car. A ceramic pad tends to be quiet and clean but can feel softer once it is hot. A metallic-based truck compound usually grips harder and holds up under heat, at the cost of more dust on the wheels. Neither is wrong; they suit different trucks.
Think honestly about the worst day your truck sees each year, not the average commute. If that day is a long downhill grade with a trailer behind you, heat tolerance should lead the decision. If it is simply a slushy drive to work, quiet stops and clean wheels may matter more. Our guide on how long brake pads last explains how load and driving habits change pad life.
Power Stop vs Hawk on the Tacoma Front Axle
Here are the three sets in full. One is Power Stop’s daily-driver upgrade for this axle, and the other two are Hawk compounds in the same HB490 shape, one built for trucks and one for spirited street driving.
Power Stop Z23-976: Carbon-Fiber Ceramic Front Pads with Hardware for Toyota Tacoma

- Carbon-fiber ceramic Z23 compound
- Two front pads plus installation hardware
- Rubberized shims, chamfered and slotted
- Low-dust, fade-resistant formula
Z23-976 is the front set from Power Stop’s Z23 line, the step above its plain replacement pads, and the listing title names the Toyota Tacoma along with the 4Runner and Tundra. It does not print model years in the title, so use the Amazon Confirmed Fit bar with your year, cab and drivetrain before ordering, since some earlier base Tacomas take a smaller pad.
The friction material is a carbon-fiber ceramic blend that Power Stop says adds stopping power over OE replacement pads while staying quiet. Rubberized shims on the backing plates and chamfered, slotted friction blocks work together to break up the vibration that causes squeal. The listing also describes a low-dust formula that resists fade, which should keep the wheels cleaner and the pedal steady through a run of stops on the way home.
The practical advantage is the box itself. Two pads and the installation hardware come together, so a Tacoma whose clips have rusted through several Michigan winters gets fresh ones in the same order. Power Stop backs the set with a 12-month or 12,000-mile limited warranty. This is a daily-driving pad, though, and a truck that tows often or carries heavy armor is better served by a truck-specific compound.
View Power Stop Z23-976 on Amazon

Hawk Performance LTS HB490Y.665: Ferro-Carbon Truck and SUV Front Pads

- LTS compound for light trucks and SUVs
- Ferro-Carbon friction material
- Rated for 100-700 F
- Hawk fit list: 2005-2023 Tacoma front
HB490Y.665 is Hawk’s LTS, or Light Truck and SUV, pad in the HB490 shape, and the .665 in the part number is the pad thickness. Hawk’s own fit list puts it on the front of the 2005 to 2023 Tacoma across the SR, SR5, TRD and Limited trims, plus the 4Runner and Lexus GX. Amazon’s listing gives no vehicles, so check your truck with the fit checker as well.
Hawk built LTS for trucks that work, naming heavily loaded pickups and moderate towing on its compound page. The Ferro-Carbon friction material is rated from 100 to 700 degrees Fahrenheit, and Hawk claims 20 to 40 percent more stopping power than stock replacement pads, along with a strong, balanced initial bite whether the brakes are hot or cold. The maker also lists low dust output and long pad and rotor life among its traits.
This set suits a Tacoma that pulls a small camper, carries a loaded bed or runs heavier bumpers and larger tires, where front brakes see more heat. Expect a firmer bite than a ceramic pad and, as many owners note, somewhat more dust. Neither the listing nor Hawk’s page mentions clips or hardware, so order a hardware kit and brake grease alongside it.
View Hawk LTS HB490Y.665 on Amazon
Hawk Performance HPS HB490F.665: High Performance Street Front Pads

- Original HPS street compound
- Same HB490 .665 shape as the LTS set
- Rated for 100-700 F
- Gentle on rotors, long pad life
HB490F.665 shares its shape, thickness and Tacoma coverage with the LTS set above, which makes it the closely related third pick: same maker and same axle, different friction recipe. Hawk lists it for the front of the 2005 to 2023 Tacoma and the matching 4Runner and GX models. As with any listing, confirm your exact truck in Amazon’s fit checker before buying.
HPS stands for High Performance Street, and the listing calls it the original compound in Hawk’s street range. The maker claims a higher friction level than stock pads, worth 20 to 40 percent more stopping power and better fade resistance than most standard replacements. Its rated range runs from 100 to 700 degrees, with 100 to 500 degrees given as the sweet spot, and Hawk describes smooth release, a consistent pedal and gentle treatment of rotors.
That optimal window is the useful clue. HPS is aimed at street driving with some enthusiasm rather than sustained heat from towing, so it fits a mostly stock Tacoma whose owner wants a firmer, more immediate pedal than a ceramic pad gives. Hawk’s LTS is the better match for heavy loads. Like the LTS listing, this one says nothing about hardware, so plan on new clips separately.
View Hawk HPS HB490F.665 on Amazon

Power Stop vs Hawk Pads Side by Side
The table repeats only what the Amazon US listings and Hawk’s own pages state. Where a listing is silent, we say so instead of guessing.
| Point | Power Stop Z23-976 | Hawk LTS HB490Y.665 | Hawk HPS HB490F.665 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Friction type | Carbon-fiber ceramic | Ferro-Carbon truck compound | HPS street compound |
| Maker heat range | Not stated on listing | 100-700 F | 100-700 F, 100-500 F optimal |
| Hardware in the box | Yes, per listing | Not stated | Not stated |
| Tacoma years named | None in title; use the fit bar | 2005-2023 on Hawk’s fit list | 2005-2023 on Hawk’s fit list |
Two gaps stand out. Power Stop includes clips and hardware, while neither Hawk listing mentions any, so budget for a clip kit if you choose Hawk. And Hawk publishes a clear fit list by model year, while the Power Stop title names the Tacoma but leaves the years to Amazon’s fit checker.
Hawk also notes on its LTS compound page that its pads are made for iron rotors and do not work with carbon ceramic discs. No Tacoma leaves the factory with carbon ceramics, but it is worth knowing if you shop Hawk for another vehicle later.
Matching a Set to the Way You Use the Truck

Start with load and towing, then weigh noise, dust and how much of the job you plan to do in your own driveway.
| Your Tacoma | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Stock commuter, mostly highway | Power Stop Z23-976 | Quiet ceramic mix, low dust, hardware included |
| Tows a trailer or carries a camper | Hawk LTS HB490Y.665 | Compound made for loaded trucks and moderate towing |
| Heavy armor, larger tires, mountain trips | Hawk LTS HB490Y.665 | Strong bite hot or cold, per Hawk |
| Unloaded truck, firmer pedal wanted | Hawk HPS HB490F.665 | Higher friction street compound, gentle on rotors |
| Rusty clips, first brake job in years | Power Stop Z23-976 | New hardware comes in the box |
If you are comparing truck pads beyond these two brands, our roundup of brake pads for pickups that tow and haul covers more lines and axles. Owners curious how Power Stop holds up against an OE-style premium brand can read our Brembo vs PowerStop comparison.
Salt, Clips and Rotors in West Michigan
Grand Rapids winters leave a film of brine on everything under the truck, and caliper brackets collect it first. Rust builds under the abutment clips until a pad sticks in its slot, wears at an angle or drags lightly against the rotor. Fresh clips and a thin coat of brake-rated grease on the slide pins prevent most of that.

The rotors deserve the same look. Hawk’s installation and bed-in guide says to resurface or replace grooved rotors, and to sand reused ones with 130-grit paper so old pad material does not mix with the new compound. If the Tacoma’s discs are pitted, lipped or near their minimum thickness, our list of rotors for the Tacoma is a good next stop.
Bedding in matters with any new pad. Hawk’s street procedure calls for 6 to 10 moderate stops from about 30 to 35 mph, then 2 or 3 harder stops from 40 to 45 mph, without dragging the brakes, followed by about 15 minutes of cooling. Follow the bed-in steps printed on whichever box you buy.
When the Problem Is Bigger Than Pads
Some symptoms point past the pads. Grinding usually means the lining is gone and steel is cutting into the rotor. A pull to one side often traces back to a sticking caliper or seized slide pin, and a pedal that sinks slowly is a hydraulic fault that no compound can fix.

Wear warnings differ from truck to car. A Tacoma typically squeals through a small metal tab when the pads run thin, while many European models use an electronic sensor and a dash light, as our explainer on the Audi brake pad warning light shows. If you hear grinding, feel a pulse or smell hot brakes after towing, our brake repair in Grand Rapids starts by measuring pads and rotors and checking calipers, hoses and fluid.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Hawk better than Power Stop for a truck?
It depends on the truck’s job. Hawk’s LTS compound is made for loaded trucks and moderate towing and claims stronger bite than stock pads. Power Stop’s Z23 is quieter and cleaner for daily driving and includes hardware. A loaded or towing Tacoma leans Hawk; a stock commuter leans Power Stop.
Do Hawk pads make more brake dust?
Hawk lists low dust output for both LTS and HPS, but owners often report more dust than from a carbon-fiber ceramic pad like the Z23. If clean wheels rank high for you, the Power Stop set is the safer choice. Dust is cosmetic and does not affect braking.
Will these pads fit a 2024 or newer Tacoma?
Don’t assume so. Hawk’s fit list for the HB490 shape stops at the 2023 Tacoma, and the redesigned truck uses different brakes. Some earlier base trucks also use a smaller pad. Enter your year, cab, drivetrain and engine in Amazon’s fit checker before ordering any set.
Do I need rear pads for a 2016-2023 Tacoma?
No. The third-generation Tacoma uses drum brakes at the rear, so it takes brake shoes rather than pads there. The rear shoes usually last much longer than the front pads, but have them checked and adjusted during any front brake job.
Would you rather have a technician fit the pads and look over the whole system? Phone 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832 any weekday from 8am to 5pm, or request a brake inspection on our contact page.
Tied up at work during our hours? Park the Tacoma at 456 Carrier St NE once we have closed, leave the keys in the after-hours drop-off along with a line about what the brakes are doing, and we will phone you after the inspection.
