456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

One Odyssey, Two Shock Brands: Monroe vs Gabriel Compared

monroe vs gabriel: two cartoon fists facing each other

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

Tired rear shocks on a family minivan creep up on you. The back end floats over highway dips, the van squats when it is loaded for a weekend away, and the rear tires start to show a scalloped wear pattern. Once you go looking for replacements, the monroe vs gabriel question appears almost at once, because both brands sell OE-replacement shocks in the same tier and both have been building them for more than a century.

We kept this comparison narrow on purpose. After a look at how each company builds and backs its parts, we set one rear shock from each brand against the other for the same van, the 2011-2017 Honda Odyssey, and added a second Monroe line that bolts to the same mounts. If you want a wider field of brands and ride styles, our roundup of shocks and struts for daily drivers covers more of them.

Quick answer

Should your Odyssey get Monroe or Gabriel rear shocks?

Either is a sound OE-replacement choice once the listing confirms for your van. Monroe’s OESpectrum 37316 names 2005-2017 Odyssey fitment and states a Limited Lifetime Warranty. Gabriel’s Ultra 70010 publishes its full dimensions, but its title stops at 2010, so check the fit first. Replace both rear shocks together.

Our Quick Picks

One rear shock from each brand for the same 2011-2017 Honda Odyssey axle, plus a second Monroe line that fits the same mounts. All three are reviewed in full below.

Monroe OESpectrum 37316 product photo
Monroe pick

Monroe OESpectrum 37316

Rear shock, Odyssey 2005-2017

Comfort-focused shock whose listing names every year of the 2011-2017 van.

SuitsOwners who want clear fitment and warranty terms in writing
View on Amazon →
Gabriel Ultra 70010 product photo
Gabriel pick

Gabriel Ultra 70010

Rear shock, Odyssey (confirm year)

Premium OE-replacement shock with its full dimensions published on the listing.

SuitsHands-on owners who check measurements before ordering
View on Amazon →
Monroe Monro-Matic Plus 33194 product photo
Second Monroe pick

Monroe Monro-Matic Plus 33194

Rear shock, Odyssey 2005-2017

Monro-Matic Plus shock with velocity proportional valving and the full year span.

SuitsMonroe buyers who want a second part number to search
View on Amazon →

Two Old Shock Makers With Different Sales Pitches

Gabriel traces its start to 1907, when Claude H. Foster built a device he called the Snubber, an early ancestor of the modern shock absorber. The Gabriel website still leads with that history. Today the brand sells Ultra shocks and struts for cars, minivans and SUVs, Ultra ReadyMount loaded strut assemblies, and truck lines such as MaxControl, GasSLX and Hijackers air shocks.

Monroe is the younger of the two, though not by much. Its brand page at DRiV, the Tenneco aftermarket business that sells it, points to more than 100 years of making ride control parts for passenger cars, light trucks, SUVs, vans and commercial vehicles. Monroe tends to sell on comfort and noise control, and many of its listings spell out a warranty and a ride guarantee.

What each brand lists for this Odyssey

For the 2011-2017 van, Monroe sells an OESpectrum bare front strut (part 72982, listed for 2012-2017) and two rear shocks reviewed here, the OESpectrum 37316 and the Monro-Matic Plus 33194. Gabriel’s Amazon US catalog for this generation is thinner. We found its Ultra 70010 rear shock, but every Gabriel front strut and ReadyMount assembly we could find was listed for the 1999-2010 vans, which is why this comparison sits on the rear axle.

If your front struts are due as well, check Gabriel’s own catalog or a local parts counter before you assume there is no match. The front and rear axles can carry different brands if they have to, but each axle should always get a matched pair.

Monroe vs Gabriel Shocks on Paper: The Odyssey Rear Axle

All three parts cross-reference one another. Gabriel’s listing names Monroe 37316 and KYB 349105 among its interchange numbers, the 37316 title says it replaces Gabriel 70010 along with KYB 349105 and 349242, and the 33194 title cites Gabriel 70010 and KYB 349105. The figures below come from the Amazon US listings, and where a listing is silent the table says so.

PointMonroe OESpectrum 37316Gabriel Ultra 70010Monroe Monro-Matic Plus 33194
Vehicle named in listing2005-2017 Honda Odyssey2005-2010 Honda Odyssey (title)2005-2017 Honda Odyssey
Body and valvingFull displaced valving, larger borePrecision twin-tube designVelocity Proportional Valving, larger bore
Piston and sealPTFE banded piston, self-lubricating fluid sealNot statedBanded piston, bronze reinforced guide, self-lubricating fluid seal
Gas chargeNitrogenNot statedNitrogen
Published dimensionsNot stated8.47 in stroke, 22.56 in extended, 14.09 in collapsedNot stated
Noise and harshnessTwin Technology isolation systemNot statedNot stated
Warranty in listingLimited Lifetime Warranty plus ride guaranteeNot statedNot stated
Monroe 37316, Gabriel 70010 and Monroe 33194 compared from their Amazon US listings for the Honda Odyssey rear

Monroe’s listings read like feature sheets, while Gabriel’s reads like a catalog card carrying the measurements a parts counter would check.

Monroe vs Gabriel: The Three Rear Shocks in Detail

Each listing below is a single shock, so plan on ordering two for the rear axle. The Odyssey’s rear coil springs sit apart from the shocks, which means this swap needs no spring compressor.

Monroe OESpectrum 37316: Rear Shock for 2005-2017 Honda Odyssey with Twin Technology Valving

Monroe OESpectrum 37316 product photo
Key features
  • Rear shock listed for 2005-2017 Honda Odyssey
  • Replaces Gabriel 70010 and KYB 349105, 349242
  • PTFE banded piston, nitrogen gas charge
  • Limited Lifetime Warranty in the listing

The 37316 is Monroe’s OESpectrum rear shock for the Honda Odyssey, and its compatibility line covers every year from 2005 through 2017. That span takes in both the 2005-2010 van and the 2011-2017 generation this page focuses on. The title lists the numbers it replaces, among them KYB 349105 and 349242 and Gabriel 70010, so it lines up directly with the Gabriel shock reviewed below.

Monroe builds it with full displaced valving tuned to the vehicle and a larger bore that it says gives more efficient damping control. A PTFE banded piston keeps a steady seal against the pressure tube, and a nitrogen gas charge is there to reduce aeration and shock fade. The Twin Technology Active Control System aims to isolate impact noise, vibration and harshness, while a self-lubricating fluid seal holds the gas in and cuts friction on the rod. An all-weather fluid with additives is meant to cope with temperature extremes.

Because the Odyssey’s rear springs are separate, this shock bolts in without a spring compressor. It suits an owner who wants a listing that names their model year outright, along with a Limited Lifetime Warranty and Monroe’s Feel the Difference Guarantee. It will not cure sagging springs or worn bushings, so check those before you blame the shocks.

View Monroe OESpectrum 37316 on Amazon

driver's hand near a digital dashboard

Gabriel Ultra 70010: Rear Twin-Tube Shock for Honda Odyssey, Interchanges with Monroe 37316

Gabriel Ultra 70010 product photo
Key features
  • Ultra rear shock, title names 2005-2010 Odyssey
  • Interchanges with Monroe 37316 and KYB 349105
  • Precision twin-tube design
  • 8.47 in stroke, 22.56 in extended length

The 70010 is a rear shock from Gabriel’s Ultra range, which the brand pitches as a premium OE replacement for passenger cars, light trucks and SUVs. Its title names the 2005-2010 Honda Odyssey, but its interchange list includes Monroe 37316 and KYB 349105, and several parts catalogs list it for the 2011-2017 van as well. Run your year and trim through Amazon’s fit checker before you order it for a newer van.

Gabriel describes a precision twin-tube design with damping aimed at smooth handling and ride comfort. Unlike many listings, this one prints the numbers a parts counter would compare: an 8.47 inch stroke, a 22.56 inch extended length and a 14.09 inch collapsed length. It also gives the mount codes, BP15 at the top and ES69 at the bottom, so you can hold the old shock up against the spec. Gabriel calls it a simple bolt-on installation engineered for long life under normal driving.

It suits a hands-on owner who likes to check dimensions before ordering, and anyone matching a Gabriel already fitted on the other side. The listing states no warranty term, so read Gabriel’s own warranty page or ask the seller. Like any shock, it cannot make up for tired springs or worn bushings.

View Gabriel Ultra 70010 on Amazon

highway through autumn trees

Monroe Monro-Matic Plus 33194: Rear Shock for 2005-2017 Honda Odyssey with Velocity Proportional Valving

Monroe Monro-Matic Plus 33194 product photo
Key features
  • Rear shock listed for 2005-2017 Honda Odyssey
  • Replaces KYB 349105 and Gabriel 70010
  • Velocity Proportional Valving, nitrogen gas charge
  • Banded piston with bronze reinforced guide

The 33194 belongs to Monro-Matic Plus, a separate Monroe line from the OESpectrum shock above, and its compatibility bullet lists the 2005-2017 Honda Odyssey. Its title names KYB 349105 and Gabriel 70010 as the parts it replaces, which places it on the same rear mounts as the other two shocks here. It also gives Monroe shoppers a second part number to try if the 37316 is hard to find.

In place of the Twin Technology system, this shock relies on Velocity Proportional Valving and an all-weather fluid whose additives are meant to cut friction and smooth rod reaction. A nitrogen gas charge works against aeration to keep the tires planted, and Monroe notes a larger bore for damping control where it applies. A self-lubricating fluid seal, a banded piston and a bronze reinforced guide are listed for durability, and Monroe says it is validated to meet OE spec.

Its listing gives no warranty term, so look up Monroe’s coverage before relying on it. Order two for the rear axle and keep the pair on this one part number rather than mixing it with a 37316.

View Monroe Monro-Matic Plus 33194 on Amazon

Where Monroe and Gabriel Really Differ

Valving and ride claims

Monroe describes full displaced valving tuned to the vehicle, plus a larger bore that it says gives more efficient damping control. Its Twin Technology system is meant to soak up impact noise and harshness before it reaches the cabin. Gabriel’s listing makes a broader claim of premium damping for smooth handling and ride comfort, without naming a valve design. Owners of both brands often describe the ride as close to factory, but impressions vary from van to van and with tire choice.

How sure you can be of the fit

This is the clearest gap between the brands. Both Monroe compatibility lines cover every model year from 2005 through 2017, while Gabriel’s title stops at 2010, even though its interchange list matches the Monroe part and several parts catalogs place the 70010 on later vans. Enter your exact year and trim in Amazon’s fit checker before you order. Treat the Gabriel as a likely fit for a 2011-2017 van rather than a promise.

couple choosing chairs in a store

Warranty, as each listing words it

The Monroe 37316 listing states a Limited Lifetime Warranty and Monroe’s Feel the Difference Guarantee. The Gabriel 70010 listing gives no warranty term at all. The Monro-Matic Plus 33194 listing is silent on coverage as well. Gabriel links a product warranty page from its own site, so read it, or ask the seller, before you count on any coverage.

A word on the front struts

Up front, the Odyssey uses MacPherson struts with the coil spring wrapped around each one. Fitting a bare strut means moving the old spring across with a compressor, and a compressed spring holds enough energy to cause serious injury if a hook slips. Read our coil spring compressor buying guide before you try it, or buy a loaded assembly that arrives with the spring already fitted.

Any front strut job should finish with an alignment check, since the strut helps set camber and toe. A rear shock swap on its own does not normally need one.

Picking Monroe or Gabriel for Your Minivan

Use the table as a quick guide, then confirm the exact part for your year and trim before you buy.

Your situationBetter fitWhy
You want the listing to name your 2011-2017 vanMonroe 37316Compatibility covers 2005-2017
You want warranty terms in writingMonroe 37316Limited Lifetime Warranty on the listing
You compare measurements before orderingGabriel 70010Stroke and lengths are published
The 37316 is hard to findMonroe 33194Same 2005-2017 Odyssey fitment
One rear shock was replaced recentlySame brand and part numberKeeps the axle matched
The van also needs front strutsMonroe, or check Gabriel’s catalogMonroe lists a 2012-2017 front strut on Amazon
Gabriel vs Monroe matched to common Odyssey rear shock situations

For most owners of a 2011-2017 van, the monroe vs gabriel choice comes down to fitment paperwork more than hardware. If the Gabriel confirms for your VIN and you like its published dimensions, it is a fair alternative. If you want a listing that names your year outright and states a warranty, the Monroe is the simpler order.

Still weighing a third brand? Our KYB vs Monroe struts comparison sets those two against each other on a Camry front corner, and our Honda strut guide covers several other Honda models.

Michigan Roads and a Loaded Minivan

Grand Rapids streets give a minivan’s rear suspension plenty of work. Freeze-thaw cycles open new potholes every spring, and an Odyssey carrying a full load of passengers and cargo hits them harder than an empty sedan would. Road salt also coats the shock bodies and mounting bolts, and that hardware can seize on a van that has seen several winters.

Spray the mounting bolts with penetrating oil the day before and have a breaker bar ready. Look over the rubber bushings that come with the new shocks and use the supplied hardware where it is included. If a bolt snaps or a thread strips, stop there and get help before a simple job turns into a lost weekend.

pegboard full of tools in a workshop

Whatever you decide in the monroe vs gabriel debate, buy shocks in axle pairs. A fresh shock on one side and a worn one on the other can make the van wander over bumps and wear the rear tires unevenly. A Monroe on the left with a Gabriel on the right causes the same imbalance, because each brand tunes its valving its own way.

When the Van Should Come to Our Shop

Before you order anything, make sure the shocks are really the cause. Floating over dips, a nose that dives under braking, oil streaks on the shock body and cupped tires are the usual clues, and our post on how to tell if struts are bad walks through each one. A squeak over speed bumps may come from sway bar links or bushings instead, as our article on why a car squeaks when going over bumps explains.

trail fork with a wooden sign

If the bolts are rusted solid, you have no safe way to support the van, or the front struts need doing at the same time, bring it to us. We handle suspension repair in Grand Rapids, and we look over the links, bushings and ball joints while the wheels are off. Steering and suspension is one of the areas where Hendrick Hoffman, our owner and head mechanic, carries both ASE and State of Michigan certification.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Monroe better than Gabriel?

Neither wins outright. On the 2011-2017 Odyssey rear, Monroe’s OESpectrum 37316 names the full year range and a Limited Lifetime Warranty, while Gabriel’s Ultra 70010 publishes exact dimensions and a twin-tube design. Choose the one that confirms for your van.

Can I fit a Gabriel shock on one side and a Monroe on the other?

It is not a good idea. Each brand tunes its valving its own way, so a mixed pair can make the rear of the van react unevenly over bumps. Buy two of the same part number for each axle.

Do I need an alignment after new rear shocks on an Odyssey?

Not usually. The rear shocks on this van do not set the wheel angles, so a shock swap alone rarely changes them. Front strut replacement is different, and an alignment check after that job protects your tires.

What about KYB shocks instead?

KYB sells Excel-G rear shocks for these vans too, and all three parts on this page cross-reference KYB numbers. This comparison covers only Monroe and Gabriel, so confirm any third brand against your exact year and trim before you order.

Van still bouncing after new shocks, or would you rather hand the job off? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, or book a suspension check through our contact page.

Your workday runs into our shop hours? Bring the van to 456 Carrier St NE once you are done, and leave it with the keys through our after-hours drop-off.