As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
A worn front end on a mid-size SUV usually sends owners shopping for complete strut assemblies, and two names come up again and again. Weighing monroe vs detroit axle shocks is really a choice between a long-established ride control brand and an online parts seller that ships its struts in left and right pairs with a long warranty.
To keep things even, we held the vehicle and the axle constant: the front of a 2013-2019 front-wheel-drive Ford Explorer. Both listings split the 2011-2019 generation at a September 2012 build date, so earlier trucks, AWD models and Police Interceptors take different parts. For a wider look at brands and styles, see our shocks and struts guide for daily drivers.
Quick answer
Is Monroe or Detroit Axle the smarter buy for Explorer front struts?
Monroe’s Quick-Strut suits owners keeping the SUV for years, with an OE-style mount, salt-tested coating and a Limited Lifetime Warranty stated by Monroe. Detroit Axle suits budget repairs on a high-mileage Explorer, shipping both front corners in one box with a 10-year warranty. Either way, confirm drivetrain and build date first.
Our Quick Picks
One complete front strut assembly listing from each brand for the 2013-2019 FWD Ford Explorer, plus a Detroit Axle kit that adds front sway bar end links. All three are reviewed in full below.

Monroe Quick-Strut 172730
OE-style loaded strut with a premium mount and a salt-tested coating.

Detroit Axle 2pc Front Struts
Both front corners in one box, backed by a 10-year warranty.

Detroit Axle FWD Front Struts Kit
Two front strut assemblies boxed with a matching pair of front sway bar end links.
Two Very Different Companies Behind the Box
Monroe has made shocks and struts for over a century and now sits under DRiV, the aftermarket group that grew out of Tenneco. Its Quick-Strut line is a loaded assembly: strut, coil spring and upper mount arrive bolted together. On its Quick-Strut product page, Monroe says each spring is matched to the model and engine size and that the assembly is backed by its Limited Lifetime Warranty and Feel the Difference Guarantee.
Detroit Axle is a Michigan-based parts retailer and distributor that sells mostly online, with a catalog running from brake rotors and control arms to complete strut assemblies. Its company overview says its parts are made to meet or exceed OEM standards. On Amazon the brand tends to sell struts as pairs or full suspension kits rather than single corners.
Shock or strut on an Explorer?
Many shoppers type “shocks” even when the front of their SUV uses struts. A strut is a damper built into a structural housing that also carries the coil spring and helps locate the wheel. The Explorer’s front corners use struts, while the rear uses separate shocks, so both brands sell rear shocks for this truck as well.
What neither listing tells you
Neither listing says whether the damper inside is a mono-tube or a twin-tube design, so we will not guess. Neither gives valving figures either. What you can compare is what each maker puts in writing: the parts included, the coating, the testing and the warranty term.
Side by Side: The Listing Facts for One Explorer Axle
The table below is built only from the Amazon US listings and the makers’ own pages. Where a listing is silent, the table says so instead of filling the gap.
| Point | Monroe Quick-Strut 172730 | Detroit Axle 2pc front set | Detroit Axle struts and links kit |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is in the box | One strut, spring and mount assembly | Two strut and spring assemblies, left and right | Two strut and spring assemblies plus two front sway bar end links |
| Vehicle named in listing | 2013-2019 Ford Explorer | 2013 (built after 9/4/2012) to 2018 FWD, 2019 2.3L | Same FWD range, Police models excluded |
| Spring compressor needed | No | No special tool required | No special tool required |
| Mount described | Premium upper mount, cuts memory steer | Not described | Not described |
| Corrosion claim | Protective coating, salt spray tested | Not stated | Not stated |
| Testing claim | Tube and weld design for durability | Impact, wear and fatigue testing | Impact, wear and fatigue testing |
| Warranty | Limited Lifetime (Monroe site), not on listing | 10-year warranty on listing | 10-year warranty on listing |
The pattern is clear. Monroe says more about how its assembly is built, from the mount to the rust coating, while Detroit Axle says less about construction but puts a longer stated warranty and a two-corner pack on the listing.
Monroe vs Detroit Axle Shocks: Three Explorer Front End Options Up Close
Every listing below covers complete front assemblies for the same FWD Explorer axle. Run your year, drivetrain, engine and build date through Amazon’s fit checker before ordering any of them.
Monroe Quick-Strut 172730: Front Strut and Coil Spring Assembly for 2013-2019 Ford Explorer

- Loaded strut, coil spring and upper mount
- Listed for the 2013-2019 Ford Explorer
- No spring compressor needed to install
- Protective coating with salt spray testing
The 172730 is a Monroe Quick-Strut, a complete corner that pairs a strut with an application-specific coil spring and a preassembled upper mount. Its Amazon listing names the 2013-2019 Ford Explorer, and parts retailer cross-references place it at the front left of front-wheel-drive models, with the 172729 as its right side partner. It is sold as a single unit, so plan on ordering both numbers for one axle.
Monroe says the spring is calibrated to the OE design to restore ride height and carry the vehicle’s weight, and that the strut, spring and mount are shaped to match the factory parts. The premium upper mount is described as helping steering feel like new while cutting noise, vibration, harshness and memory steer. A steel tube and weld design is listed for structural strength, and a protective coating checked with salt spray testing is meant to slow rust.
The listing itself names no warranty term, though Monroe’s own Quick-Strut page states a Limited Lifetime Warranty and its Feel the Difference Guarantee. It suits an Explorer that will stay in the driveway for years, especially one that sees salted roads. It does not fit AWD or Police Interceptor models, so check the fit bar first.
View Monroe Quick-Strut 172730 on Amazon

Detroit Axle 2pc Front Struts: Left and Right Complete Assemblies for 2013-2019 FWD Ford Explorer

- Two complete strut and spring assemblies
- 2013 to 2018 FWD and 2019 2.3L Explorer
- No special tool needed to install
- 10-year warranty stated on the listing
This Detroit Axle set holds two front strut and coil spring assemblies, one for each side, for the front-wheel-drive Ford Explorer. The listing spells the fit out with care: 2013 FWD models built after September 4, 2012, the 2014-2018 FWD trucks, and 2019 models with the 2.3L four-cylinder, with Police models excluded. AWD 3.5L Explorers need a separate Detroit Axle listing.
Detroit Axle describes the assemblies as complete and ready to install, with no extra work or special tool needed, so the old spring never has to be compressed. The company says its parts go through impact, wear and fatigue testing, and the listing states a 10-year warranty. Its company overview adds that parts are made to meet or exceed OEM standards, though the listing does not describe the mount, the coating or the damper design.
Because both corners come in one order, the axle stays matched without hunting down a second part number. That makes the set a practical fit for an older, high-mileage Explorer where the goal is a solid repair rather than a long-term upgrade. Owners who care most about rust protection details or a published mount design will find more of that information on the Monroe listing.
View Detroit Axle 2pc Front Struts on Amazon
Detroit Axle FWD Front Struts Kit: Strut Pair and Two Front Sway Bar End Links for 2013-2019 Ford Explorer

- Two strut and coil spring assemblies
- Two front sway bar end links in the kit
- 2013 to 2018 FWD and 2019 2.3L Explorer
- 10-year warranty named on the listing
This kit is Detroit Axle’s route for owners who want more of the front end renewed in a single order. It packs two front strut and coil spring assemblies together with two front sway bar end links, aimed at the same front-wheel-drive Explorer range: 2013 trucks built after September 4, 2012, the 2014-2018 FWD models and 2019 models with the 2.3L engine. Police models are left off the fit list.
The strut assemblies carry the same listing claims as the brand’s two-piece set. They arrive complete, need no extra work or special tool, and go through impact, wear and fatigue testing, and the 10-year warranty appears here as well. As with that pair, the page gives no detail on the damper type, the upper mount or any coating, and it says nothing about how the end links are built.
End links use a small ball joint at each end, and those joints loosen with age and can knock over broken pavement. With the front corners already apart for struts, fitting fresh links during the same visit spares a second round of labor later. The kit makes the most sense when a clunk over bumps is part of the complaint, and less sense if the links were renewed recently.
View Detroit Axle FWD Front Struts Kit on Amazon

Buying a Matched Pair and Getting the Fit Right
Struts should always be replaced in axle pairs. With either Detroit Axle listing that happens by default, because each holds both corners. With Monroe you order two part numbers, and retailer cross-references pair the 172730 on the left with the 172729 on the right. Never put a Monroe on one side and a Detroit Axle on the other, since the two are tuned differently.
Drivetrain matters more than year on this generation. AWD Explorers, including the Sport and the Police Interceptor Utility, take different front struts, and Detroit Axle sells separate AWD listings. Trucks built before September 2012 also use a different part. If the fit checker shows a blue information icon, read the note before you buy.

Because all three picks ship loaded assemblies, you do not have to compress the old spring. That removes the riskiest step of a strut job. If you ever choose a bare strut instead, read our coil spring compressor buying guide first, because a spring under load can cause serious injury if a tool slips.
Which Brand Fits Which Explorer Owner
There is no independent lab data comparing these assemblies, so the verdict comes down to what each maker promises and how long you plan to keep the truck. Use the table as a starting point, not a final word.
| Your situation | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Keeping the Explorer for many more years | Monroe Quick-Strut | Lifetime coverage stated by Monroe, detailed build claims |
| High-mileage SUV, tight repair budget | Detroit Axle pair | Both corners in one box, 10-year warranty on listing |
| Steering drifts or clunks at the top mount | Monroe Quick-Strut | Mount described as cutting memory steer and noise |
| You want one order and one box | Detroit Axle pair | Left and right sold together |
| Car sees salt every winter | Monroe Quick-Strut | Coating with salt spray testing stated |
| Sway bar end links also worn | Detroit Axle struts and links kit | Two front end links ship with the struts |
For a family hauler that tows a small trailer or carries a full load most weekends, the Monroe’s stated spring matching to model and engine is a sensible reason to spend more. For a second car with years of wear on it, the Detroit Axle pair gets both sides done in one order, and its struts and links kit also handles a knocking sway bar. If the monroe vs detroit axle shocks decision still feels close, our KYB vs Monroe strut comparison shows how Monroe stacks up against another factory supplier.
Road Salt, Potholes and a Heavy SUV
An Explorer weighs well over two tons, and West Michigan roads give its front struts a hard life. Spring potholes from freeze-thaw cycles hammer the mounts, and road salt eats at spring seats, strut bodies and the knuckle bolts you will need to remove. Spray those bolts with penetrant the night before, and expect at least one to fight you.

Corrosion protection is where the brands differ most for local drivers. Monroe names a protective coating and salt spray testing, while neither Detroit Axle listing mentions a coating. Whichever you fit, rinse the wheel wells during winter and look over the springs for rust each time the tires come off.
New front struts change the Explorer’s camber and toe once the knuckle is unbolted, and Monroe publishes a tech tip on alignment after strut replacement for that reason. Book an alignment right after the swap. Skipping it can chew up the inner edges of a set of tires in one season.
Before You Order: Is It Really the Struts?
A bouncy nose, a dive under braking, oily strut bodies and cupped tires all point to worn struts, and our article on how to tell if struts are bad walks through each sign. Squeaks over speed bumps can also come from sway bar links or bushings, which our guide on why a car squeaks when going over bumps explains.

If you would rather not wrestle rusted knuckle bolts or lift a heavy SUV at home, our team handles suspension repair in Grand Rapids on foreign and domestic vehicles. While the corner is apart we look at the sway bar links, tie rods and ball joints too. Hendrick Hoffman, who runs the shop, is ASE and State of Michigan certified for steering and suspension.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Detroit Axle struts as good as Monroe?
There is no independent test that settles it. Monroe gives more detail on the mount, spring matching and rust coating, and states a Limited Lifetime Warranty on its site. Detroit Axle lists impact, wear and fatigue testing and a 10-year warranty, and it ships both corners together.
Will the FWD parts fit an AWD Explorer?
No. AWD models, including the Sport and Police Interceptor Utility, use different front struts, and both brands sell separate listings for them. Enter your full vehicle details in Amazon’s fit checker and read any qualifier notes before you buy.
Do I need a spring compressor for these assemblies?
No. All three picks use complete units with the spring already installed, so they bolt in as a full corner. You still need a safe way to support the SUV and the right sockets for the knuckle and top mount nuts.
Should I align the Explorer after new front struts?
Yes. Unbolting the strut from the knuckle can shift camber and toe, even if the steering wheel looks straight. An alignment protects the tires and keeps the SUV tracking true.
Explorer still wandering or knocking after new struts? Ring 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832 between 8am and 5pm, Monday to Friday, or request a front end check on our contact page.
Busy during shop hours? Drop the SUV and its keys with us after closing, and our Carrier St NE shop in Creston will take it from there.
