As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
Put a small lift on a fifth-generation 4Runner and the rear shocks are usually the first parts owners want to change. The bilstein vs icon choice comes up again and again on that truck, because both brands sell a monotube rear shock built for it at a mild lift height. They share a basic layout, yet they differ in materials, valving and what happens when the shock wears out.
To keep the comparison fair, this guide uses one truck and one position: the rear axle of a 2010-2024 Toyota 4Runner with roughly 1 to 2 inches of rear lift. That is the range where both listings below overlap. If you drive a car or crossover instead, our guide to shocks and struts for daily drivers covers a wider spread of brands.
Quick answer
Should a lifted 4Runner run Bilstein or ICON rear shocks?
Choose the Bilstein 5100 if you want a sealed, fit-and-forget monotube for a truck that mostly sees pavement and the odd trail. Choose ICON’s 2.0 aluminum shock if you want vehicle-specific valving and a shock the maker can rebuild. Match the listed lift range to your truck before ordering.
Our Quick Picks
One rear shock listing from each brand for the same 2010-2024 4Runner with a mild rear lift, plus ICON's remote reservoir version of its shock for heavier off-road use. All three are reviewed in full below.

Bilstein 5100 33-313146
Sealed lift-height shock that goes in and needs no service plan.

ICON 2.0 VS 56505
Truck-specific valving in a shock ICON can rebuild later.

ICON 2.0 VS RR 56505R
Extra oil capacity in a separate canister for long, hot runs.
Two Shock Makers With Different Priorities
Bilstein is a German company with a long history in gas-pressure monotube dampers, and its 5100 line has been a common lift-height shock for Toyota trucks for years. The 5100 is sold as a complete steel-bodied unit. When it eventually loses damping, the usual plan is to replace it rather than send it in for service.
ICON Vehicle Dynamics is a California suspension maker that focuses on trucks and SUVs, and its company background page says the brand develops and tests its parts in race conditions as well as on the street. Its rear shocks for the 4Runner use aluminum bodies and parts. ICON also runs a factory rebuild program, which changes how you think about the cost of owning one.
Why both use a single tube
A monotube shock holds its oil and a pressurized nitrogen charge in one tube, separated by a floating piston. Because the working piston is large and the outer wall is the only wall, heat leaves the shock quickly. That helps damping stay steady on long washboard roads, where a smaller twin-tube shock can start to fade.
Both shocks in this matchup use that layout. The real differences sit in the details: the body material, how the piston is valved for the 4Runner, and whether the oil and gas can be refreshed later.
Internal or remote reservoir
ICON sells its 4Runner rear shock in two forms. The internal reservoir version keeps everything inside the shock body, so it bolts in like any ordinary rear shock. The remote reservoir version moves extra oil and the gas charge into a separate canister connected by a hose, which adds fluid volume and gives heat another place to go.
A remote reservoir makes sense on a truck that spends hours on rough dirt, sand or rocky two-tracks. For a commuter that sees a few gravel roads each summer, the extra canister mostly means more to mount and keep clean.
Bilstein vs ICON Shocks on the Same 4Runner Rear Axle
The table below lines up the two internal reservoir shocks using only what their Amazon US listings state. Note the lift ranges first, because they decide whether either one suits your truck at all.
| Point | Bilstein 5100 33-313146 | ICON 2.0 VS 56505 |
|---|---|---|
| Vehicles listed | 2010-2024 4Runner SR5 | 2003 and newer 4Runner, 2007-2014 FJ Cruiser |
| Rear lift range | 0.5 to 2 inches | 1 to 3 inches |
| Design | Monotube, high gas pressure | Nitrogen-charged monotube, internal reservoir |
| Body and parts | Corrosion-resistant construction | 6061 aluminum rod end, top cap and internals, 5/8 inch chrome shaft |
| Valving | Not described beyond fade-free damping | Linear/digressive piston with vehicle-specific valving |
| Sold as | Single shock | Single shock |
The ICON listing gives far more build detail, while the Bilstein listing sticks to the monotube basics. Neither listing states a warranty term, so check the box or ask the seller before you count on coverage.
Bilstein vs ICON: The 4Runner Rear Shocks in Detail
Each listing below is one rear shock, so plan on ordering two of the same part for the axle. Enter your year, trim and lift on Amazon’s fit checker before buying, since trims with KDSS or X-REAS and the redesigned 2025 truck can call for different parts.
Bilstein 5100 33-313146: Monotube Rear Shock for 2010-2024 4Runner with 0.5-2 Inch Lift

- Single rear shock for the 2010-2024 4Runner SR5
- Listed for 0.5 to 2 inches of rear lift
- Monotube body with high gas pressure
- Corrosion-resistant construction
The 33-313146 is a single rear shock from Bilstein’s 5100 line, and its Amazon listing names the 2010-2024 4Runner SR5 with 0.5 to 2 inches of rear lift. That range starts lower than the ICON in this comparison, so it also covers a truck that is only a touch above factory height. Owners of other trims, or of trucks with KDSS or X-REAS, should check the fit tool before ordering.
Bilstein builds the shock around a monotube body, and the listing says its high gas pressure keeps the oil from foaming so damping stays consistent as the shock works. A foamed shock loses control over the axle on long rough roads, which is why this design matters on a heavy SUV. The listing also points to materials chosen to resist corrosion and wear, a fair concern under a truck that sees road salt.
This is a sealed unit with no rebuild schedule, which suits an owner who wants to install the shocks and stop thinking about them. It is a good fit for a 4Runner that commutes all week and heads down a gravel road now and then. It is not built for a lift beyond 2 inches, and the listing gives no warranty term.
View Bilstein 5100 33-313146 on Amazon

ICON 2.0 VS 56505: Internal Reservoir Rear Shock for 4Runner and FJ Cruiser with 1-3 Inch Lift

- Rear shock for 2003 and newer 4Runner and 2007-2014 FJ Cruiser
- Listed for 1 to 3 inches of rear lift
- Nitrogen-charged monotube with internal reservoir
- 6061 aluminum rod end, top cap and internals
ICON’s 56505 is a single rear shock from its 2.0 VS range, where VS stands for vehicle specific. The listing covers the 2003 and newer 4Runner and the 2007-2014 FJ Cruiser at 1 to 3 inches of rear lift, which takes in the fifth-generation truck. A 2025 or newer 4Runner is a different design with its own ICON part numbers, so confirm your year before you order.
The shock is a nitrogen-charged monotube with an internal reservoir, filled with 5WT oil that the listing says gives consistent damping across a wide temperature range. A one-piece piston with a linear and digressive profile carries valving set for these trucks. ICON uses a 5/8 inch chrome-plated hardened steel shaft to resist pits, plus a 6061 aluminum rod end, top cap and internals to save weight without giving up strength.
Because ICON offers a factory rebuild with new seals and oil, this shock can be refreshed instead of thrown away when it wears. It suits a lifted 4Runner that spends real time on washboard, two-tracks or rocky roads. It is not meant for a truck at stock height, and the listing does not state a warranty term.
View ICON 2.0 VS 56505 on Amazon
ICON 2.0 VS RR 56505R: Remote Reservoir Rear Shock for 4Runner and FJ Cruiser with 1-3 Inch Lift

- Remote reservoir version of the ICON 56505
- Listed for 1 to 3 inches of rear lift
- Nitrogen-charged monotube with external canister
- 5/8 inch chrome-plated hardened steel shaft
The 56505R is the remote reservoir version of the ICON rear shock above, listed for the same 2003 and newer 4Runner and 2007-2014 FJ Cruiser at 1 to 3 inches of rear lift. It is the step to consider if the internal reservoir shock looks right but your trips involve hours of rough ground. As with any lift part, check your exact year and lift height before you buy.
Instead of keeping the gas charge inside the body, this shock moves it to a separate canister joined by a hose. That adds oil capacity and gives heat more surface to escape, which helps the damping hold up on long washboard stretches with a loaded cargo area. The rest of the build matches the 56505, with 5WT oil, a one-piece linear and digressive piston, a 5/8 inch hardened chrome shaft and 6061 aluminum parts.
The extra canister needs a secure mounting spot and a careful hose route away from the exhaust and moving parts. ICON’s rebuild service also covers its remote reservoir shocks. It suits an overland 4Runner that carries gear and covers long dirt roads, and it is more than most commuters need.
View ICON 2.0 VS RR 56505R on Amazon

Which Shock Fits the Way You Drive
The brand name matters less than your daily routine. Think about the miles you put on the truck in a normal month, not the one big trip you have planned for next year.
| How the 4Runner is used | Better match | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Commuting with a spacer lift, light trail use | Bilstein 5100 | Sealed unit with no service schedule to track |
| Stock height or a half-inch lift | Bilstein 5100 | Its listed range starts at 0.5 inch, while ICON starts at 1 inch |
| Regular gravel, washboard and two-track weekends | ICON 2.0 internal reservoir | Valving tuned for the truck, and it can be rebuilt as it wears |
| Long desert-style runs or a heavily loaded overland build | ICON 2.0 remote reservoir | Extra oil volume helps control heat over hours of rough road |
Owners on 4Runner forums often describe the 5100 as durable and a little firm, and the ICON as more controlled over repeated bumps. Those are opinions shaped by tires, air pressure and cargo, so use them as a rough guide rather than a measurement. If you are still weighing Bilstein against another lift-height brand, our Bilstein and Rough Country strut comparison covers that question on a leveled F-150.

Shock service is the biggest ownership difference in the bilstein vs icon decision. ICON’s factory shock service page describes a rebuild for its whole shock line that includes new seals and fresh oil, and it publishes service intervals for street and mixed street and dirt use. A Bilstein 5100 skips that upkeep, but once it wears out you buy a new shock.
Fitting Notes for the 4Runner Rear
The fifth-generation 4Runner has a solid rear axle with coil springs that sit apart from the shocks. That means a rear shock swap needs no spring compressor, only good jack stands and a way to keep the axle from dropping when the shock comes off. Most owners raise the body, support it on stands and keep a floor jack lightly under the axle.
Front coilovers are a different job. If you plan to rebuild the front struts on your own, read our coil spring compressor guide first, because a loaded spring can do real harm. Any front lift or strut change also calls for an alignment afterward, and upper arms often come up once a 4Runner goes past 2 inches of lift, as our 4Runner upper control arm guide explains.

Keep the same shock on both sides of the axle, and pair the rear with a front setup of similar character. Mixing a firm rear with a soft, worn front can make the truck pitch and wallow over dips. Ride height matters too: a shock that is too short for your lift will top out, while one that is too long can bottom inside its own travel.
Winter Salt and West Michigan Roads
Grand Rapids roads get a heavy dose of salt each winter, and the lower shock mounts on a 4Runner sit right in the spray. Expect the bolts to be crusty on an older truck, so soak them with penetrating oil the night before. Freeze-thaw potholes in spring are a good test of whether your current shocks are still doing their job.
Aluminum shock bodies do not rust the way bare steel does, but they can still pit and corrode if salt sits on them for months. On a remote reservoir shock, check the hose and clamps along with the canister when you rinse the underside in April. Whatever you pick in the bilstein vs icon matchup, a spring wash and a quick look for oily shock bodies pays off.

When a Shop Should Take a Look
Not sure your shocks are finished? Our article on how to tell if struts are bad covers bounce, leaks and uneven tire wear, and those checks carry over to rear shocks. A creak over driveway lips can also come from bushings or links, which our guide on why a car squeaks when going over bumps walks through.
If the bolts refuse to move, the truck wanders after a lift, or you want the whole suspension checked first, our team offers suspension repair in Grand Rapids. Hendrick Hoffman, our owner and head mechanic, holds ASE and State of Michigan certification in steering and suspension work. He has been in automotive service since 2005.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ICON better than Bilstein?
Not for every truck. In the bilstein vs icon comparison, the Bilstein 5100 suits owners who want a sealed shock with no upkeep, while the ICON 2.0 suits owners who want truck-specific valving and a shock that can be rebuilt. Your lift height and how often you drive on dirt should decide it.
Do ICON shocks need to be rebuilt?
ICON offers a factory rebuild with new seals and oil and publishes service intervals for street and dirt use. You can run the shocks without it, but servicing them on schedule keeps the damping closer to new.
Will ICON rear shocks fit a stock-height 4Runner?
The ICON 56505 listing names a 1 to 3 inch rear lift, so it is not meant for a truck at factory height. The Bilstein 33-313146 lists a range starting at half an inch, which sits closer to stock.
Can I use Bilstein up front and ICON in the rear?
It will bolt on, and some owners do it. The two ends will be valved differently, though, so the truck may feel less balanced over bumps. Keep the same part on both sides of each axle at a minimum.
Rear end still bouncing or clunking after a lift? Give 456 AutoFix a call at 616-279-3832 between 8am and 5pm, Monday to Friday, or set up a suspension check through our contact page.
Busy during the workday? Our after-hours drop-off lets you leave the 4Runner at 456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 on your own schedule.
