456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

Old Name or New Line? KYB vs Aisin Struts on a 2006-2012 RAV4

kyb vs aisin: captivating winter scene of a snowy mountain highway surrounded by frosty trees and landscape

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

Search for front struts for an older Toyota RAV4 and two Japanese names keep turning up side by side. KYB has sold replacement struts in the US for a long time, while Aisin, a Toyota group supplier most mechanics know for transmissions and timing kits, has only recently listed its own strut and coil spring assemblies on Amazon. This kyb vs aisin guide sorts out what each brand actually sells and which one fits the job in front of you.

To keep the comparison honest, we hold one corner still: the front suspension of the 2006-2012 RAV4, a compact crossover that plenty of West Michigan families still drive every day. We look at KYB’s complete Strut-Plus unit, Aisin’s SAKT-01917 assembly and KYB’s bare Excel-G strut for that same corner. Driving something else? Our roundup of shocks and struts for daily drivers covers a wider spread of cars.

Quick answer

Should you buy KYB or Aisin struts for a RAV4?

Choose KYB if you want an established strut maker and the option of a complete Strut-Plus unit or a bare Excel-G strut. Choose Aisin if you want one preassembled strut, spring and mount from a Toyota group supplier, with 2006-2012 RAV4 fitment printed right in the listing. Either way, confirm side and engine first.

Our Quick Picks

KYB's Strut-Plus and Aisin's strut and spring assembly for the same 2006-2012 RAV4 front, plus KYB's bare Excel-G strut as a closely related third pick. All three are reviewed in full below.

KYB Strut-Plus SR4461 product photo
KYB pick

KYB Strut-Plus SR4461

Complete strut assembly, front right, RAV4

KYB's ready-to-bolt corner unit, built around its own Excel-G strut.

SuitsOwners renewing the whole front corner in one job
View on Amazon →
AISIN SAKT-01917 product photo
Aisin pick

AISIN SAKT-01917

Strut and spring assembly, front, 2006-2012 RAV4

A Toyota group supplier's complete front corner, with model years on the listing.

SuitsBuyers who want fitment years stated up front
View on Amazon →
KYB Excel-G 339031 product photo
Bare strut option

KYB Excel-G 339031

Excel-G gas strut, front right, RAV4

KYB's damper-only option for when your spring and mount are still sound.

SuitsDIYers who own a proper spring compressor
View on Amazon →

Two Japanese Suppliers, Two Different Paths

KYB is a Japanese damper maker that supplies original equipment shocks and runs a large replacement catalog in North America. Its RAV4 parts on Amazon fall into two lines. Excel-G is the bare gas strut, calibrated to bring back factory handling, and Strut-Plus wraps an Excel-G strut together with a matched coil spring and upper mount.

Aisin comes at suspension from a different direction. Its corporate history page traces Aisin Seiki to a 1965 merger of two sister companies and notes that in 1970 it opened the Fujioka Proving Ground, which Aisin calls the first full quality test facility with a driving course built by a parts maker. Most US shops know the name from automatic transmissions, water pumps and belt kits, the territory our Gates and Aisin timing belt kit comparison covers.

The strut assemblies are a newer branch. Amazon lists them under the AISIN AFTERMARKET name with SAK part numbers, each one described as a preassembled strut, coil spring and upper components with a validated damping design. The listings do not say where the assemblies are built, so we will not guess.

That is the real shape of the kyb vs aisin question. One side is a damper specialist with years of strut catalogs behind it. The other is a large Toyota group supplier stretching its replacement range into complete front corners.

Complete Assembly or Bare Strut on a Third-Gen RAV4

A bare strut is only the damper. To fit one, you compress the old coil spring, strip the top mount and rebuild the corner around the new strut, reusing your spring, mount, bearing and dust boot. A complete assembly shows up already built, so the whole corner bolts in as one piece.

On a RAV4 that has lived through ten or more Michigan winters, the complete unit usually makes more sense. The mount rubber and the spring coating have aged right alongside the strut, and renewing them together spares you a second teardown later. A bare strut still earns its place when the springs and mounts were replaced recently or are in clean, solid shape.

Spring compression is the risky step. A loaded coil spring holds a lot of energy, and a compressor that slips can let it go without warning. If you choose the bare-strut route, read our coil spring compressor buying guide before you pick up a wrench.

KYB vs Aisin Struts for the 2006-2012 RAV4 Front: Three Units Up Close

Each unit below is listed for the front of the 2006-2012 Toyota RAV4. The two KYB parts are passenger-side numbers, while the Aisin listing gives its position as front left and right, so read every listing for side and quantity. Parts sellers often catalog the four-cylinder and V6 versions of this RAV4 separately, so enter your year, model and engine in Amazon’s fit checker before you order.

KYB Strut-Plus SR4461: Complete Front Right Strut Assembly with Excel-G Strut for Toyota RAV4

KYB Strut-Plus SR4461 product photo
Key features
  • Strut, upper mount and coil spring in one unit
  • Listed for Toyota RAV4, built around an Excel-G strut
  • Application-engineered KYB spring for ride height
  • Front right, cross-referenced for 2006-2012 RAV4

The SR4461 belongs to KYB’s Strut-Plus range, the brand’s complete corner unit that pairs a strut with a new coil spring and upper mount. KYB’s listing says it is designed for proper ride height and original handling on Toyota RAV4s, but it names neither model years nor a side. The Gabriel ReadyMount listing for the 2006-2012 RAV4 front right cross-references SR4461, which places this unit at the passenger-side front corner of that generation.

Inside sits a KYB Excel-G strut with what the listing calls a stronger steel outer shell and application-specific damping valves. The spring is engineered to match that strut, and KYB says it should hold ride height longer and carry the vehicle’s weight without spoiling ride quality. Because the parts arrive assembled and engineered for exact fitment, the corner goes in as one piece with no spring work at the bench.

This unit suits an owner who wants to renew the strut, spring and mount together and skip the spring compressor entirely. It is less suited to anyone who wants printed year coverage before buying, since the listing leaves that to Amazon’s fit checker. Order the matching driver-side KYB number for the other corner, and confirm both against your engine.

View KYB Strut-Plus SR4461 on Amazon

curved mountain road with signposts

AISIN AFTERMARKET SAKT-01917: Front Strut and Coil Spring Assembly for 2006-2012 Toyota RAV4

AISIN SAKT-01917 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for Toyota RAV4 2006-2012
  • Preassembled strut, coil spring and upper components
  • Gas charged twin-tube damper, 22.22 in extended
  • Installation manual included in the box

SAKT-01917 comes from Aisin’s AISIN AFTERMARKET line, which combines a strut, coil spring and upper components in one preassembled unit. Its listing states compatibility with the 2006-2012 Toyota RAV4, the clearest year coverage of the three units here. Aisin frames the line around its history as an automotive supplier since 1965, and says the validated damping design supports stable suspension response and proper ride height.

The specification line describes a gas charged, twin-tube strut with an extended length of 22.22 inches, listed for the front left and right positions. Its reference list mixes Toyota right-side and left-side front numbers, and the listing does not spell out whether one unit or a pair ships, so check the quantity before you order. An installation manual comes in the box, and Aisin pitches the unit as a direct replacement.

This assembly suits a RAV4 owner who wants the full corner renewed and likes seeing model years printed on the listing. It may also appeal to anyone already running Aisin parts elsewhere on the car. Because the line is new on Amazon, there is little long-term owner feedback yet, and the listing names no warranty term.

View AISIN SAKT-01917 on Amazon

KYB Excel-G 339031: Front Right Gas Strut for Toyota RAV4, Replaces Toyota 4851009U70

KYB Excel-G 339031 product photo
Key features
  • Bare front right strut, Excel-G gas design
  • Replaces Toyota 4851009U70 and 4851080284
  • Seamless cylinder with Teflon coated piston band
  • Triple chrome plated rod and multi-lip oil seals

The 339031 is KYB’s Excel-G bare strut for the RAV4, sold as the damper alone. Its title lists the Toyota part numbers it replaces, including 4851009U70 and 4851080284, and several of those same numbers appear on the Aisin SAKT-01917 reference list, which ties both parts to the same front right position. KYB says the strut is calibrated to restore the RAV4’s original handling and control.

The listing describes a seamless working cylinder matched with a Teflon coated piston band for a positive seal, plus a triple chrome plated piston rod and multi-lip oil seals meant to reduce wear. Solid seamless mounting eye rings and bolt bushings are there to stop rattles. It is the same strut family KYB builds into its Strut-Plus units.

Because only the damper comes in the box, you will move your existing spring, mount and boot onto it, which means compressing the spring. That suits a home mechanic with the right compressor and healthy springs, or a shop rebuilding the corner. It does not suit a rusty, high-mileage RAV4 with tired mounts, where a complete assembly saves you a second job later.

View KYB Excel-G 339031 on Amazon

person uses a grinder on metal

Side by Side: What Each Listing Promises

The table lines up the three units using only what their Amazon listings state. Where a listing stays silent, the table says so instead of filling the gap with a guess.

PointKYB Strut-Plus SR4461AISIN SAKT-01917KYB Excel-G 339031
FormatStrut, coil spring and upper mountStrut, coil spring and upper componentsBare gas strut only
Fitment namedToyota RAV4, years not listedToyota RAV4 2006-2012Toyota RAV4, by OE part numbers
SideFront right, by cross-referenceListed as front left and rightFront right
DamperExcel-G strut insideGas charged, twin-tubeExcel-G gas strut
Spring compressor neededNoNoYes, to move your spring
Install guideNot mentionedInstallation manual includedNot mentioned
KYB vs Aisin struts for the 2006-2012 RAV4 front, compared from the Amazon listings

No column wins outright. Aisin’s listing is the clearest about model years, while KYB offers two formats from one brand and a strut it calibrates specifically for this Toyota. Gabriel’s Ultra ReadyMount G57205 is another complete front right unit for this generation, and we already review it in our guide to struts for Toyota models.

lonely road in a foggy Norwegian landscape

If you already own a sound spring compressor and your springs look healthy, the Excel-G is the most direct swap of the damper alone. If you want the whole corner renewed in one session, your kyb vs aisin decision narrows to the two complete units. At that point, let the fit checker and the side markings on each listing settle it.

Road Salt, Potholes and an Aging RAV4 Front End

Third-generation RAV4s are well into their second decade, and around Grand Rapids that age shows up underneath first. Winter brine creeps into the lower strut bolts and spring seats, and the spring thaw opens potholes that pound the front struts for weeks.

A day before the job, soak the lower strut-to-knuckle bolts and the top nuts with penetrating oil. Look over the sway bar end links while you are in there, because a rusty link often clunks and gets blamed on the strut. Any bolt that comes out stretched or badly corroded should be replaced, not reinstalled.

quiet curved road bordered by lush trees under a tranquil sky

Plan on doing both front corners together. A fresh strut on one side and a tired one on the other leaves the RAV4 diving unevenly under braking and leaning differently in each direction. For the kyb vs aisin choice, that means pairing the KYB passenger unit with its matching driver-side number, or ordering enough Aisin units to cover both sides, rather than mixing brands across the axle.

When the Strut Swap Belongs in a Service Bay

Not every front-end noise means the struts are finished. Our guide on how to tell if struts are bad walks through the bounce test, oily strut bodies, nose dive and cupped tires. A creak over speed bumps can also come from dry sway bar bushings or a worn mount, as our article on why a car squeaks when going over bumps explains.

beautiful fall foliage with a bright red tree along a rural road under a clear blue sky

The RAV4’s front strut helps set camber and toe, so book an alignment check after any strut replacement. If the bolts refuse to budge, the springs need compressing and you lack the tool, or you would simply rather hand it off, our team handles suspension repair in Grand Rapids. Owner Hendrick Hoffman, who leads the work in our bays, carries ASE and Michigan state certification covering steering and suspension.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Aisin as good as KYB for struts?

Both are Japanese suppliers with long histories, but their strut lines differ in age. KYB’s Excel-G and Strut-Plus parts have been listed on Amazon for years, while Aisin’s strut and coil spring assemblies are a recent addition. For the 2006-2012 RAV4, choose by which listing confirms your exact side, year and engine.

Who makes Aisin strut assemblies?

They are sold under the AISIN AFTERMARKET brand, and Aisin traces its roots to Aisin Seiki, formed in Japan in 1965. The Amazon listings do not say which factory builds the strut assemblies. If that matters to you, check the box or ask the seller before installing.

Can I replace just one front strut on my RAV4?

It is better to replace both front struts together. A new strut on one side and a worn one on the other can make the RAV4 dip unevenly under braking and feel unsettled over bumps.

Do I need an alignment after replacing RAV4 front struts?

Yes, have it checked. The front strut helps hold the wheel angle, and removing it can shift camber and toe enough to wear the tires unevenly over the next few thousand miles.

RAV4 thumping over railroad crossings or bouncing after every dip? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday from 8am to 5pm, or send your strut questions through our contact page.

Working the same hours we do? Our after-hours drop-off at 456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, lets the car arrive whenever your own day wraps up.