As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
Honda owners who change their own oil eventually stand in the aisle holding two small cans: the genuine Honda filter and a Mobil 1 Extended Performance filter that costs a little more. The mobil 1 vs honda oil filter question comes down to what each maker puts inside the can, what each one promises on the box, and how long your engine actually keeps its oil.
To keep the comparison fair, we stick to one fitment: the Honda 15400-PLM-A02 spin-on, which Honda has superseded to 15400-RTA-003. Honda fits this can to a long list of gas engines, and we use the 3.5-liter V6 in the Pilot and Odyssey as our running example. Year and engine still matter, so check the part finder on each Amazon listing, or ask a Honda parts counter to look up your VIN, before you order.
Quick answer
Should a Honda wear the genuine filter or a Mobil 1?
Choose the Honda 15400-RTA-003 if you follow the Maintenance Minder and want the factory part at a modest cost. Choose the Mobil 1 M1-110 if you run full synthetic toward the long end of the Minder and want published efficiency and capacity figures. Buy the Honda case of five if you change oil often.
Our Quick Picks
For the Mobil 1 vs Honda oil filter choice on the 15400-PLM-A02 / RTA-003 can, here are the two compared filters plus a related third pick: the genuine Honda filter sold as a case of five.

Mobil 1 M1-110
Mobil 1's long-drain can in the Honda PLM-A02 size.

Honda 15400-RTA-003
Honda's current number for the PLM-A02 filter.

Honda 15400-PLM-A02 Case of 5
The same Honda filter by the case, for regular changes.
Reading the Fine Print on Each Box
Both brands now use a synthetic blend media rather than plain paper, and both use a silicone anti-drainback valve. That valve is a small rubber flap that keeps oil in the filter after shutdown, so the engine is not running dry for the first second of a cold start. On paper, then, the two cans share more than most forum arguments suggest.
The real gap is in what each maker chooses to print. Mobil 1 publishes hard numbers on its M1-110 listing: a multi-pass efficiency rating, a contaminant capacity in grams and a burst strength in psi. Honda describes construction instead, such as metal end caps and a metal center tube, and leaves the change interval to the car’s own oil-life system.
| What the listing says | Mobil 1 M1-110 | Honda 15400-RTA-003 | Honda 15400-PLM-A02 (case of 5) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Media | Synthetic fiber blend | Not stated on listing | High-density synthetic blend |
| Efficiency figure | 99.6 percent multi-pass rating | Not stated on listing | Not stated on listing |
| Anti-drainback valve | Silicone, where the OEM requires one | Not stated on listing | Silicone |
| Strength and capacity | Up to 615 psi, 28.0 grams of capacity | Not stated on listing | Metal end caps and center tube |
Read the table as a list of maker statements, not a lab result. The single RTA-003 listing says little about construction, but Honda’s own case listing confirms that the RTA-003 and the PLM-A02 are the same genuine filter under two numbers. A blank cell means the listing is silent, not that the feature is missing.
One Honda Can, Several Part Numbers
Honda part numbers change over time while the filter on the shelf stays interchangeable. The 15400-PLM-A01 gave way to the PLM-A02, which Honda has now superseded to 15400-RTA-003, and some boxes still show the older 15400-R5G-H01. Depending on dealer stock, the box that arrives may carry any of these numbers.
Mobil 1 has its own version of this. The M1-110 and the newer M1-110A are the same size can, and Mobil sells some packs under both numbers at once. If a store lists only one of them, that is not a sign of a different thread or gasket.
What you cannot skip is the fit check. Honda specifies other filter numbers for some engines, so a can that looks right is not proof of fit. Enter your year, model and engine in the Amazon part finder for each listing, and if the two disagree, trust the number printed on the filter that came off your engine. Our guide to oil filters for Honda engines covers the other common brands that fit this can.
Mobil 1 vs Honda Oil Filter: Three Cans Side by Side
Below are the two filters being compared, plus the genuine Honda filter sold by the case for owners who stock up. All three are listed for the PLM-A02 / RTA-003 application. Confirm your own vehicle on each listing before ordering.
Mobil 1 M1-110 Extended Performance: Synthetic Blend Oil Filter with 99.6% Multi-Pass Rating, 2 Pack

- 99.6 percent multi-pass efficiency rating
- Synthetic fiber blend media, 28.0 grams capacity
- Withstands 9x normal pressure, up to 615 psi
- Silicone anti-drainback valve where the OEM requires
The M1-110 is the Honda-size can in Mobil 1’s Extended Performance line, and Mobil also sells it under the newer M1-110A number. This listing is a pack of two, which covers two oil changes or one change plus a spare for the garage shelf. The title does not name vehicles, so run your Honda through the Amazon part finder and compare the result with the number on your old filter.
Mobil 1 is specific about what this can does. The listing quotes a 99.6 percent multi-pass efficiency rating from an advanced synthetic fiber blend media, and a total capacity of 28.0 grams, which it says is double the leading brand. The shell is rated to withstand nine times normal operating pressure, up to 615 psi, and a silicone anti-drainback valve is fitted where the original equipment calls for one.
Those figures matter most to owners who run a full synthetic oil and let the Maintenance Minder count down close to its limit, or who tow with a V6 Pilot or Odyssey and put real load on the oil. On short, frequent intervals much of that capacity simply goes unused. Mobil designs it for longer drain intervals, but your Minder code, not the box, should decide when it comes off.

Honda 15400-RTA-003: Genuine Spin-On Oil Filter, Replaces 15400-PLM-A02

- Current Honda number for the PLM-A02 can
- Fits vehicles that use PLM-A01 or PLM-A02
- Replaces superseded 15400-R5G-H01
- Single filter, screw-on installation
The 15400-RTA-003 is the part number Honda now uses for the filter that most owners know as the PLM-A02. The listing describes it as the current replacement for that part and for the older 15400-R5G-H01, and says it suits every vehicle that calls for a 15400-PLM-A01 or PLM-A02. This is a single filter, so it suits an owner who buys one at each oil change.
The listing keeps its claims simple. It is built to fit Honda engines, it screws on like any spin-on can, and it is the part Honda’s own service schedule assumes you are using. There is no published micron figure or mileage claim here, because Honda leaves the interval to the Maintenance Minder in the car rather than to the filter box.
That makes this the straightforward choice for a Honda that gets its oil changed when the Minder asks, whether the oil is the factory grade synthetic or a conventional blend. It also keeps the paperwork tidy if you like your service records to show genuine parts. The listing text is unclear about country of origin, so we do not rely on it; the part number is what matters, and it should match the one your parts counter gives for your VIN.
View Honda 15400-RTA-003 on Amazon
Honda 15400-PLM-A02: Genuine OEM Oil Filter with Silicone Anti-Drainback Valve, Case of 5

- Genuine OEM Honda part, five filters
- High-density synthetic blend media
- Metal end caps and center tube
- Silicone anti-drainback valve
This listing sells the genuine Honda filter by the case, five cans under the PLM-A02 number that Honda has since moved to 15400-RTA-003. Honda’s own case listing confirms the two numbers are the same filter, so your box may carry either one. It is the closest relative to the single RTA-003, which is why it sits here as the third pick rather than another brand.
Unlike the single listing, this one describes how the filter is put together. It lists high-density synthetic blend media, metal end caps and a metal center tube for stability and wear resistance, and a silicone anti-drainback valve that Honda says lasts longer than the traditional nitrile type. That valve helps hold oil in the can between starts, which counts on a cold West Michigan morning.
A case makes sense if you change oil on more than one Honda or Acura that shares this can, or if you prefer shorter intervals than the Minder suggests. Store the spares somewhere dry and keep the boxes until you use them, since the printed number is your fit reference. If your engine calls for a different Honda number, this case will not fit it, so check your VIN first.
View Honda 15400-PLM-A02 Case of 5 on Amazon

Letting the Maintenance Minder Set the Pace
Most current Hondas do not run on a fixed mileage schedule. The Maintenance Minder watches engine temperature, trip length and load, counts the oil life down as a percentage, and shows a code when service is due. Your owner’s manual explains what each code covers, including when the filter should be replaced alongside the oil.
That system matters more to this choice than any number on a box. If the Minder calls for an oil change every 5,000 to 7,500 miles, a genuine Honda filter has plenty of capacity for the job, and a can rated for much longer will be thrown away with most of its life unused. The extra capacity of the Mobil 1 earns its keep only when you run full synthetic oil to the far end of the oil-life reading, or when the engine does hard work between changes. For a broader look at timing, see our article on how often to change oil.

West Michigan winters change the math. Short trips in freezing weather leave moisture and fuel in the crankcase, and the Minder will usually shorten the interval to match. Cold starts are also when the anti-drainback valve matters most, and both listings point to silicone, which Honda’s case listing says lasts longer than traditional nitrile.
The oil itself counts for just as much on a January morning. A thin, cold-rated viscosity reaches the bearings faster than any filter choice can help, so match the grade on your oil filler cap or in the manual. Our roundup of motor oil for cold weather explains what the winter rating on the bottle tells you.

Warranty Worries, Records and Professional Help
A common worry is that a non-Honda filter will cost you warranty coverage. Federal law says otherwise: under 15 U.S. Code 2302, a warrantor generally cannot make coverage depend on you using a brand-name part unless that part is supplied free. What protects you is proof, so keep receipts that show the filter number, the date and the mileage of every change.
The swap itself is a short job on most of these engines. Fit a new crush washer on the drain plug, wipe clean oil on the new filter’s gasket, spin the filter on by hand until it seats, and finish with the turn printed on the can. If the old one is stuck, our list of oil filter wrenches for Honda owners covers cap and band styles that grip this size.

Some problems point beyond the filter. A flickering oil pressure light, a rattle at startup or oil that darkens far faster than the Minder expects deserve a closer look. Our technicians handle oil changes in Creston for foreign and domestic vehicles, and our owner, Hendrick Hoffman, has worked in automotive service since 2005 and carries ASE and State of Michigan certification in engine repair.
Comparing more than two brands? Our side-by-side of six spin-on oil filter brands adds WIX, Purolator and others, and the Mobil 1 and WIX comparison runs the same exercise on a Ford fitment.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Mobil 1 oil filter better than a genuine Honda filter?
Not in any way that matters on a normal Honda schedule. Mobil 1 publishes a 99.6 percent multi-pass rating and 28 grams of capacity, while Honda lists synthetic blend media, metal end caps and a silicone valve. Both suit an engine changed when the Maintenance Minder asks.
Is Honda 15400-RTA-003 the same as 15400-PLM-A02?
Yes. Honda has superseded the PLM-A02 to the RTA-003, and its listings describe them as the same genuine filter under two numbers. Boxes from dealer stock may carry either number, and both fit vehicles that call for the PLM-A01 or PLM-A02.
Will a Mobil 1 filter void my Honda warranty?
Fitting a correct aftermarket filter does not by itself void a new car warranty under federal law, unless the maker supplies the part free. Keep receipts with the part number, date and mileage, since records are what count if an engine claim comes up.
Can I leave a Mobil 1 filter on my Honda for two oil changes?
We would not. The Maintenance Minder and your owner’s manual set when the filter is due, and the long mileage claim on a Mobil 1 box is a ceiling for extended synthetic intervals. Replace the filter whenever the Minder code calls for it.
Want a second opinion on which can goes on your Honda? Give our front desk a call at 616-279-3832 on any weekday between 8am and 5pm, or set up an oil change through our contact page.
Busy during shop hours? Leave the car with our after-hours drop-off at 456 Carrier St NE, and we will take it from there.
