456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

Charging a REDTOP or YELLOWTOP: The Best Battery Tender for Optima Battery Care

best battery tender for optima battery: red classic car with its hood open showing the engine

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

OPTIMA batteries cost more than ordinary flooded batteries, so it pays to charge them the way the maker intends. The best battery tender for Optima battery owners is a microprocessor charger with a true AGM setting that stays inside the voltage and amp limits OPTIMA publishes, and can sit on the battery for a whole Michigan winter.

Here we cover what OPTIMA says about charging its spiral-cell batteries, how the REDTOP, YELLOWTOP and BLUETOP differ in daily use, and five maintainers and chargers that fit those rules. If you want a wider look at chargers in general, our winter car battery charger roundup compares more models.

Quick answer

What charger should I use on an OPTIMA battery?

Use a smart charger with a dedicated AGM mode, never a gel setting. OPTIMA recommends no more than 10 amps for charging and about 1 amp for float. The OPTIMA D200+ is the maker’s own 2-amp maintainer, the Clore PL2410 handles badly drained batteries, and the Victron IP67 suits BLUETOP boat batteries.

Our Quick Picks

Three chargers that cover most OPTIMA owners, from a stored REDTOP to a boat BLUETOP. All five picks are reviewed below.

OPTIMA D200+ product photo
Maker's own

OPTIMA D200+

2A max · AGM, flooded, LiFePO4

OPTIMA's compact maintainer, built to keep its own batteries topped up.

SuitsStored cars and trucks with a REDTOP or YELLOWTOP
View on Amazon →
Clore PL2410 product photo
For drained batteries

Clore PL2410

2/6/10A · 12V and 24V

Shop-grade charger with a soft start for badly discharged batteries.

SuitsYELLOWTOPs that get worked hard and run low
View on Amazon →
Victron Blue Smart IP67 7A product photo
Marine pick

Victron Blue Smart IP67 7A

7A · IP67 · Bluetooth

Sealed, app-controlled charger made for damp and marine use.

SuitsBLUETOP batteries in boats and RVs
View on Amazon →

OPTIMA’s Own Charging Rules, in Plain Terms

Every OPTIMA in the REDTOP, YELLOWTOP and BLUETOP lines is a sealed AGM battery built from tightly wound spiral cells. That matters because the charger has to treat it as AGM, not as a flooded or gel battery. OPTIMA spells out its numbers in a blog post on whether OPTIMA batteries can be recharged, written for owners using another brand of charger.

  • Regular charging: a maximum of 10 amps, at 13.8 to 15.0 volts.
  • Float or maintenance charging: 1 amp maximum, at 13.2 to 13.8 volts.
  • Charger type: microprocessor controlled, with a specific AGM setting.
  • Settings to skip: “gel” or combined “gel/AGM” modes, which OPTIMA says may not fully charge its batteries and could damage them over time.
  • Heat: a warm battery during charging is normal, but stop at once if it feels hot to the touch.

OPTIMA also points out that an alternator is built to keep a healthy battery topped up, not to rebuild a deeply discharged one. Relying on driving to recover a flat OPTIMA can start a cycle of jump starts that wears out the battery or the alternator.

REDTOP, YELLOWTOP and BLUETOP: One Charging Profile, Different Jobs

The color tells you how the battery is meant to be used, while the charging rules above stay the same for all three. What changes is how deeply the battery tends to get drained and where it lives between uses.

  • REDTOP: a starting battery for vehicles with a working alternator and a mostly stock electrical system. A small maintainer is usually all it needs in storage.
  • YELLOWTOP: a dual-purpose deep-cycle battery for vehicles with heavy accessory loads such as winches, sound systems or lighting. These are the batteries most likely to be run flat, so a charger with recovery ability earns its place.
  • BLUETOP: the marine and RV line. OPTIMA describes the dark gray case as the starting version and the light gray case as the dual-purpose one, and a waterproof charger suits a battery that spends time on a boat.

OPTIMA sells the Digital 400+ and D1200+ chargers, which we already cover in our guide to the AGM battery charger picks. The list below adds the smaller D200+ and four chargers from other makers.

Best Battery Tender for Optima Battery Owners: Five Chargers Reviewed

Specifications come from each Amazon listing or the maker’s own pages.

1. OPTIMA D200+: 2A Maintainer and Lithium Charger for 12V AGM and Flooded Batteries

OPTIMA D200+ product photo
Key features
  • Charges at up to 2 amps, per OPTIMA
  • Programs for AGM, flooded and LiFePO4 batteries
  • Auto maintain mode for long-term storage
  • LED glow bar and five-bar pre-charge test

The D200+ is the smallest charger in OPTIMA’s own lineup, added in 2023 to sit below the larger Digital 400 and Digital 1200 units. OPTIMA rates it at a maximum of 2 amps, which keeps it well under the company’s 10-amp ceiling for charging and makes it a natural fit for holding a parked vehicle’s battery at full charge. The listing says it handles AGM and flooded lead-acid batteries as well as 12-volt lithium iron phosphate packs.

A built-in auto maintain mode takes over once the battery is full, and the listing describes it as safe for short and long storage periods. A five-bar pre-charge button gives a rough state of charge before you start, and a glow bar on the body changes color as the charger moves from analyzing to charging, conditioning and maintaining. OPTIMA also lists spark-free connection, reverse polarity protection and over-temperature protection, plus a weatherproof case with cable wraps and an optional wall bracket.

The trade-off is speed. OPTIMA itself notes that the D200+ can take two to six times as long as its bigger chargers to refill the same battery, so it is a poor choice for quickly recovering a drained YELLOWTOP. For a car that sits all winter on a healthy battery, that slower pace isn’t a drawback.

View OPTIMA D200+ on Amazon

2. Clore PRO-LOGIX PL2410: 10A 12V/24V Smart Charger with Soft Start and Temperature Compensation

Clore PL2410 product photo
Key features
  • Selectable 2, 6 or 10 amp charge rates
  • Charges and maintains 12V and 24V batteries
  • Soft Start mode for severely depleted batteries
  • Recondition mode and temperature compensation

Clore Automotive builds its PRO-LOGIX chargers for professional use, and the PL2410 is a compact member of the range that charges and maintains both 12-volt and 24-volt batteries. Its top rate of 10 amps sits right at the limit OPTIMA recommends for regular charging, and the 2-amp and 6-amp positions give gentler options for an overnight top-up or a smaller battery. Clore and its retailers list AGM and spiral-wound batteries among the types it supports.

The feature that stands out for OPTIMA owners is Soft Start, which the listing describes as a mode for severely depleted batteries. That addresses the situation OPTIMA warns about, where a battery pulled down below about 10.5 volts is ignored by a basic charger. A multi-phase charging process, a recondition mode for distressed batteries and temperature compensation round out the feature list, and the charger finishes by switching to maintenance once the battery is full.

The 24-volt ability makes it useful for anyone who also looks after a two-battery boat or equipment setup. It is a larger, more involved unit than a plug-and-forget maintainer, so owners who only need to hold a stored REDTOP may find a smaller charger simpler to live with.

View Clore PL2410 on Amazon

Close-up of the terminals on a group of cylindrical batteries

3. Victron Energy Blue Smart IP67 12V 7A: Waterproof Bluetooth Charger with 7-Step Algorithm

Victron Blue Smart IP67 7A product photo
Key features
  • 12V, 7A output with a 7-step charge algorithm
  • Built-in Bluetooth and VictronConnect app
  • Fully encapsulated, waterproof housing
  • Low-current recovery for deeply discharged batteries

Victron Energy is widely known in the boating and RV world, and its Blue Smart IP67 line is built for wet places. The 12-volt, 7-amp model is fully encapsulated, and the listing calls it waterproof, shockproof and ignition protected, so it can be mounted near a battery on a boat or in a damp storage building. That makes it a sensible match for a BLUETOP, OPTIMA’s marine and RV battery.

Built-in Bluetooth links the charger to the VictronConnect app on a phone, tablet or laptop, where you can check charger and battery status and change its settings. The listing describes a 7-step charging algorithm that charges, maintains and protects the battery over time. When a battery has been run down hard, the charger tries to recover it with a low current first and resumes normal charging once enough voltage appears at the terminals.

Its 7-amp output is below OPTIMA’s 10-amp limit for charging, and the app lets you confirm the battery type setting rather than guessing from a row of lights. The waterproof housing and app control come at a higher cost than a basic maintainer, which is hard to justify for a REDTOP that never leaves a dry garage.

View Victron Blue Smart IP67 7A on Amazon

4. OptiMate 4 Quad Program TM631: 1.25A 9-Step Charger for AGM and Lithium Batteries

OptiMate 4 Quad Program product photo
Key features
  • 9-step program at 1.25 amps
  • AGM, gel and standard 4-60Ah, LiFePO4 2-15Ah
  • Recovers batteries from as low as 0.5 volts
  • Ring terminal harness and battery clips included

OptiMate is TecMate’s charger brand, and the 4 Quad Program is a 1.25-amp unit from its Gold Series that runs a 9-step process. The listing rates it for 12-volt AGM, gel and standard batteries from 4 to 60 amp hours, plus lithium iron phosphate batteries from 2 to 15 amp hours. Check the amp-hour figure on your OPTIMA’s label against that range, since some of the larger deep-cycle sizes may sit above it.

Its strongest point for an OPTIMA owner is recovery. The listing says it tests the battery before and after charging and can bring back a dead-flat lead-acid or lithium battery from as low as 0.5 volts, well below the 10.5-volt point where OPTIMA says some chargers give up. The low output also sits close to the 1-amp float figure OPTIMA suggests for maintenance.

The quad program refers to four settings for charging through compatible BMW CAN-bus or Triumph powered sockets as well as directly at the battery, so it also suits a garage that houses a motorcycle. A ring terminal harness and a set of battery clips come in the box. At 1.25 amps, refilling a big, badly drained battery takes patience, so treat it as a maintainer with recovery ability rather than a fast charger.

View OptiMate 4 Quad Program on Amazon

Battery charger with indicator lights mounted on a wooden post

5. Schumacher SC1300: 1.5A 6V/12V Maintainer with AGM Support and Ring Leads

Schumacher SC1300 product photo
Key features
  • 1.5-amp charging and maintaining
  • 6V and 12V, standard, AGM and gel batteries
  • Desulfation mode for battery reconditioning
  • 17-inch ring leads, engine bay mountable

Schumacher’s SC1300 is a small 1.5-amp charger and maintainer for 6-volt and 12-volt batteries. The listing names standard, AGM and gel battery types and lists cars, trucks, SUVs, motorcycles, ATVs and marine batteries among its uses, which covers the REDTOP in a weekend car or the YELLOWTOP in a seldom-used truck. Its low output keeps it close to the float current OPTIMA recommends for keeping a battery full.

Schumacher describes it as a three-in-one device that charges, maintains and reconditions batteries, with a desulfation mode aimed at extending battery life. Smart trickle charging is meant to hold a battery over long periods without overcharging, and reverse polarity protection guards against a mixed-up connection. It runs on household power through a 15-inch cord and connects with 17-inch ring leads.

Because it can be mounted in the engine compartment with a Schumacher bracket sold separately, it suits owners who want a charger that stays with the vehicle and plugs in when parked. Make sure the AGM selection is in use on an OPTIMA, since OPTIMA cautions against gel settings on its batteries. With a modest 1.5-amp rate, it is meant for upkeep rather than bringing back a deeply drained battery in a hurry.

View Schumacher SC1300 on Amazon

Which Charger Fits Your OPTIMA?

Start with how the battery is used and how often it goes flat, then check the charger’s AGM setting before you buy.

Your OPTIMATypical needChargers that fit
REDTOP in a stored car or truckLow-current upkeep for monthsOPTIMA D200+, Schumacher SC1300
YELLOWTOP feeding winches or audioFaster recharge after deep useClore PL2410, Victron IP67 7A
BLUETOP on a boat or RVWaterproof charger, app monitoringVictron IP67 7A
Battery drained below 10.5 voltsRecovery mode for a low-voltage batteryClore PL2410, OptiMate 4, Victron IP67 7A
OPTIMA plus a lithium bike battery in the same garageAGM and LiFePO4 programs in one unitOPTIMA D200+, OptiMate 4
OPTIMA battery uses matched to the chargers reviewed in this guide
Off-road pickup splashing through dirt by a lake

The best battery tender for Optima battery care is the one whose settings match how you use the battery. Whichever unit you choose, confirm it charges within OPTIMA’s 10-amp ceiling on the setting you plan to use. A higher-output charger with a 2-amp or 6-amp position works fine when you pick the lower rate for an overnight top-up.

Reviving a Flat OPTIMA and Getting Through Winter

A common complaint from owners is a dead YELLOWTOP that the charger refuses to start on. OPTIMA explains that once a battery drops below 10.5 volts, some chargers may not recognize it or deliver current. Its workaround is a parallel charging technique, where a charged battery gives the charger a voltage it can see.

That method involves live cables between two batteries, so many owners prefer a charger with its own low-voltage recovery mode. If a recovered battery still won’t hold a charge for more than a day, it has likely reached the end of its life.

Boat under a plastic winter cover at a dock

For storage in a West Michigan pole barn or unheated garage, a few habits help:

  1. Charge it fully before parking: a maintainer holds a full battery, it doesn’t rebuild one quickly.
  2. Check the mode light: confirm AGM, not gel or lithium, every time the charger loses power.
  3. Keep the charger off a wet floor: road salt and melting slush are hard on clamps and housings.
  4. Bring boat batteries home or keep them on a waterproof charger: a BLUETOP left discharged in a cold boat all winter is a battery you may be replacing in spring.

When the Battery Isn’t the Real Problem

Technician working at an electronics repair bench

A healthy OPTIMA that keeps going flat usually points to something else on the vehicle. A module that never sleeps, an aftermarket amplifier or a stuck relay can drain a battery in days, and our article on why a car battery dies overnight runs through the usual suspects. A weak alternator can also leave a deep-cycle battery chronically undercharged.

Finding a parasitic draw takes a meter, time and wiring diagrams. Our car electrical repair in Grand Rapids covers draw testing, battery load tests and charging system checks, so you know whether the problem is the battery or the vehicle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do OPTIMA batteries need a special charger?

No. OPTIMA says most quality chargers and maintainers will work, as long as they are microprocessor controlled and have an AGM setting. Stay within 10 amps for charging and about 1 amp for float, and avoid gel modes.

Can I charge an OPTIMA on a gel setting?

OPTIMA advises against it. Its batteries are AGM, not gel, and the company warns that gel or combined gel/AGM settings may leave the battery undercharged and could damage it over time.

Why won’t my charger work on a dead OPTIMA?

Below about 10.5 volts, some chargers don’t detect a battery at all. A charger with a recovery or soft start mode may bring it back, or OPTIMA’s parallel charging method can help an older charger see the battery. If it won’t hold a charge afterward, replace it.

Is it safe to leave a maintainer on an OPTIMA all winter?

Yes, a smart maintainer that drops to a float or maintain mode can stay connected through storage. Check the status light every few weeks, keep the charger dry and make sure it is still set to AGM after any power cut.

OPTIMA still going flat in Grand Rapids, even on a maintainer? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, or book a battery and drain test through our contact page.

Can’t make it during the day? Use our after-hours drop-off. We’re at 456 Carrier St NE in Creston.