As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
The 4.0 inline six is known for running forever and for wearing a film of oil across the head. Choosing the best valve cover gasket for Jeep 4.0 engines is mostly a matter of matching the model year, because the covers changed in the mid-1990s and the gaskets changed with them.
Below we sort six gasket listings by the years they name and cover the parts and mistakes that decide whether the seal lasts. If you are chasing other 4.0 parts too, our oil filter guide for the Jeep 4.0 is a good companion read.
Quick answer
Which valve cover gasket fits my Jeep 4.0?
It depends on the year. A 1996-2006 4.0 takes the set cross-referenced to Fel-Pro VS 50458 R and Mopar 53020758, ideally with new grommets. A 1987-1995 engine takes a different gasket, such as Fel-Pro VS 50522 T. Confirm year, model and engine on Amazon before you order.
Our Quick Picks
Two picks for 1996-2006 engines and one for 1987-1995 engines; three more sets are reviewed below.

Fel-Pro VS 50458 R
The part number most 1996-2006 cross-references point to.

PHILTOP VS50458R Set
A complete later-engine kit with fresh bolt grommets in the box.

Fel-Pro VS 50522 T
A carrier-style gasket that resists crushing on early covers.
The 1995/1996 Split: Which Gasket Your 4.0 Takes
Every listing here falls on one side of a line at the 1995 and 1996 model years. The engine is still a 4.0, but the cover and its gasket changed.
- 1987-1995 engines: Cherokee XJ through 1995, Wrangler YJ 4.0 from 1991 to 1995, Comanche MJ and the 1993-1995 Grand Cherokee ZJ. Listings cross-reference Fel-Pro VS 50522 T and Mopar 5093785AA, and some also cover the older 4.2.
- 1996-2006 engines: Cherokee XJ from 1996 to 2001, Grand Cherokee ZJ and WJ from 1996 to 2004, and the Wrangler TJ from 1997 to 2006. Listings cross-reference Fel-Pro VS 50458 R, VS50266 and Mopar 53020758AA.
- Not covered here: the 2.5 four-cylinder, which uses its own gasket. Sellers often list 2.5 parts beside 4.0 parts, so read the engine size.
Rubber, Cork-Rubber and the Small Parts That Matter
Fel-Pro’s valve cover gasket overview describes three families: PermaDryPlus molded rubber over a rigid carrier with torque limiters, PermaDry molded rubber for covers designed around it, and Blue Stripe cork-rubber, which is compressible but easy to handle.
On a 4.0, the parts around the gasket matter almost as much as the gasket itself:
- Grommets: the bolt grommets on later engines harden with age, so a set that includes new ones helps.
- Torque limiters: sleeves that stop the bolt from crushing the gasket, the classic way a new 4.0 gasket splits.
- Locating tabs: they hold the gasket in the cover groove while you lower it onto the head.
- Sealant: use it only where the service manual or gasket instructions call for it. Our RTV gasket maker roundup covers which products suit oil-side seals.
Best Valve Cover Gasket for Jeep 4.0: Six Listings Checked for Fit
Three suit 1996-2006 engines and three suit 1987-1995 engines; none fits both. Run your year, model and engine through each listing’s fit checker before you order.
1. Fel-Pro VS 50458 R: 4.0L Valve Cover Gasket Set for 1996-2006 Jeep

- Listed for 1996-2001 Cherokee, 1996-2004 Grand Cherokee, 1997-2006 Wrangler TJ
- Conformable material for imperfect sealing surfaces
- Set includes the parts needed for the repair
- Amazon Confirmed Fit check on the listing
Fel-Pro’s VS 50458 R is the set that most later 4.0 cross-reference charts lead back to, and the listing names the 1996-2001 Cherokee, the 1996-2004 Grand Cherokee and the 1997-2006 Wrangler TJ. If your Jeep sits on the later side of the 1995/1996 split, this is the reference point the other sets in this guide copy.
The listing describes a conformable formulation made for the repair environment, meaning heads and covers that are no longer perfectly flat after years of heat cycles. Fel-Pro states that its sets include every part needed for the job unless the listing notes otherwise. Retailers describe the material in slightly different ways, so look at the photos and the package contents to see exactly which gasket and grommets arrive in the box.
This set suits owners who want a known maker’s part on a 1996-2006 engine and plan to clean the surfaces properly before fitting it. It does not fit 1987-1995 engines, which use a different cover, and it is not for the 2.5 four-cylinder sold in the same Jeeps. Enter your year, model and engine in the Amazon fit checker, and look for any qualifier notes, before you add it to the cart.
View Fel-Pro VS 50458 R on Amazon
2. PHILTOP VS50458R: Valve Cover Gasket with 15 Grommets for 1996-2006 Jeep 4.0L

- Fits 1997-2006 Wrangler, 1996-2004 Grand Cherokee, 1996-2001 Cherokee 4.0L
- Includes 1 gasket and 15 grommets
- Cross-refs VS 50458 R, VS50266, 53020758AA/AB/AC
- Rubber formulation for uneven surfaces
PHILTOP sells this set as a replacement for the VS 50458 R pattern and lists a long run of cross-reference numbers, including Mopar 53020758AA, AB and AC and VS50266. The fit chart covers the 1997-2006 Wrangler, the 1996-2004 Grand Cherokee and the 1996-2001 Cherokee with the 4.0, which matches the later gasket family.
The main draw is the package: one valve cover gasket plus 15 grommets. On a later 4.0, the grommets that sit under each cover bolt go hard over time, and reusing them is a common reason a fresh gasket seeps at the bolt holes. Having new grommets in the same box means you are not hunting for a separate kit halfway through the job. The listing describes a rubber formulation that conforms to imperfect sealing surfaces and holds up to engine heat.
This set suits a driveway job on a high-mileage TJ, XJ or Grand Cherokee where the original grommets are cracked or flattened. It is not for 1987-1995 engines. Compare the gasket shape in the photos with your old one, confirm the fit on Amazon with your year, model and engine, and tighten the cover bolts to the service manual figure.
View PHILTOP VS50458R Set on Amazon

3. BCtimingparts Valve Cover Gasket Set: Molded Rubber with Grommets for 1996-2006 Jeep 4.0L

- Lists Grand Cherokee 1996-2004, Wrangler TJ 1997-2006, Cherokee 1996-2001
- Molded rubber gasket with grommets
- Cross-refs VS50458R and VS50266
- Heat and oil-resistant material
BCtimingparts offers another take on the later 4.0 set, built around a molded rubber gasket with grommets. Its fit chart lists the 1996-2004 Grand Cherokee, the 1997-2006 Wrangler and TJ, and the 1996-2001 Cherokee, all with the 4.0 inline six, and it cross-references VS50458R and VS50266.
Molded rubber is the style many 4.0 owners lean toward for this cover, because it springs back into shape and tends to tolerate a little uneven clamping better than older cork designs. The listing describes heat and oil-resistant material and a precision-made shape meant to drop into the cover groove. The grommets come with it, so the bolt sealing is refreshed at the same time as the main gasket.
This kit suits owners on the later engine who want a molded rubber set with grommets and are comfortable checking the part against the original before fitting it. The listing asks buyers to confirm the model and part number first, which is sound advice for any aftermarket gasket. It does not fit 1987-1995 engines or the 2.5 four-cylinder, so run the Amazon fit check with your year, model and engine before you order.
View BCtimingparts Valve Cover Set on Amazon
4. Fel-Pro VS 50522 T: Molded Rubber Valve Cover Gasket for 1987-1995 Jeep 4.0L

- Fits 1987-1995 Cherokee, 1991-1995 Wrangler, 1993-1995 Grand Cherokee
- Molded rubber over a rigid carrier
- Built-in torque limiters and locating tabs
- Sealing beads for imperfect surfaces
For an early 4.0, Fel-Pro’s VS 50522 T is the gasket most charts point to. The listing covers the 1987-1995 Cherokee, the 1987-1992 Comanche, the 1991-1995 Wrangler and the 1993-1995 Grand Cherokee, along with several older 4.2 applications such as the CJ7 and Grand Wagoneer.
The design is molded rubber over a rigid carrier, which Fel-Pro says resists high heat. Rubber sealing beads cover the small dips and scratches on a cover or head that has seen many years, and locating tabs hold the gasket in position while you set the cover down. The built-in torque limiters keep the bolts from crushing the gasket, which matters on an engine where over-tightening is the classic way to split a new seal.
This set suits owners of early XJ, YJ, MJ and ZJ models who want a gasket that is hard to install wrong. It does not fit 1996 and later engines, which take the later gasket family. Clean both surfaces thoroughly, check the cover flange for bends from past over-tightening, and confirm your year, model and engine with the Amazon fit checker before ordering.
View Fel-Pro VS 50522 T on Amazon

5. DNJ VC1120: Valve Cover Gasket Set for 1986-1995 Jeep 4.0L and 4.2L

- Lists 4.0L and 4.2L Jeep engines from 1986 to 1995
- Fit chart broken down by VIN engine code
- Complete installation package
- Oil-resistant gasket material
DNJ’s VC1120 stands out for the detail in its fit chart. Instead of a simple year range, the listing names each application by engine and VIN code, from the 1987-1988 Cherokee and Comanche 4.0 with VIN code M to the 1991-1995 Cherokee and Wrangler 4.0 with VIN code S and the 1993-1995 Grand Cherokee. It also covers several 4.2 engines from the CJ7, J10 and Wrangler.
That VIN-level breakdown is useful on an older Jeep, where years of ownership changes can leave you unsure what is under the hood. The eighth character of the VIN usually tells you the engine code, so you can check it against the chart before you buy. DNJ describes the set as a complete installation package made from oil-resistant material.
This set suits owners of early 4.0 and 4.2 engines who like to verify fit by VIN rather than by model name alone. It is not for 1996 and later engines. The listing gives fewer construction details than the Fel-Pro sets, so compare the photos with your old gasket and confirm year, model and engine with the Amazon fit checker before ordering.
6. PORC Off Road Products Valve Cover Gasket: Rubber Seal for 1987-1995 Jeep 4.0L and 4.2L

- Fits YJ, XJ, MJ and ZJ applications from 1987 to 1995
- Rubber gasket construction
- References OE part number 5093785AA
- Listing notes the original cover used RTV
PORC Off Road Products sells this rubber valve cover gasket for early Jeeps and references the original part number 5093785AA. The listing covers the Wrangler YJ with the 4.2 from 1987 to 1990 and with the 4.0 from 1991 to 1995, plus the 1987-1995 Cherokee XJ, the 1987-1992 Comanche MJ and the 1993-1995 Grand Cherokee ZJ with the 4.0.
One detail in the listing helps explain why early 4.0 covers can be tricky: it notes that the original valve cover was sealed with RTV. If you pull the cover and find a bead of old sealant instead of a gasket, that is normal for these engines, and every trace of it has to come off before a rubber gasket can seal. Plan time for careful scraping of both the head and the cover flange.
This gasket suits owners of early XJ, YJ, MJ and ZJ models who want a part tied to the factory number. It gives fewer construction details than the Fel-Pro VS 50522 T, so read the listing closely. The seller asks buyers to verify model, year, engine, cover type and the OE number before ordering, and the Amazon fit checker is the place to do that.
View PORC Off Road Gasket on Amazon
Quick Fit Table by Jeep and Year
Find your Jeep and year, then confirm the matching listing.
| Jeep | 4.0 years | Gasket family | Sets from this list |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cherokee XJ | 1987-1995 | VS 50522 T / 5093785AA | Fel-Pro VS 50522 T, DNJ VC1120, PORC |
| Cherokee XJ | 1996-2001 | VS 50458 R / 53020758AA | Fel-Pro VS 50458 R, PHILTOP, BCtimingparts |
| Wrangler YJ | 1991-1995 | VS 50522 T / 5093785AA | Fel-Pro VS 50522 T, DNJ VC1120, PORC |
| Wrangler TJ | 1997-2006 | VS 50458 R / 53020758AA | Fel-Pro VS 50458 R, PHILTOP, BCtimingparts |
| Grand Cherokee ZJ | 1993-1995 | VS 50522 T / 5093785AA | Fel-Pro VS 50522 T, DNJ VC1120, PORC |
| Grand Cherokee ZJ and WJ | 1996-2004 | VS 50458 R / 53020758AA | Fel-Pro VS 50458 R, PHILTOP, BCtimingparts |
The Comanche MJ follows the early pattern through 1992. If your Jeep is missing from a listing’s chart, treat that as a no.

Doing the Job Without Making a New Leak
On most 4.0 Jeeps the cover comes off once the crankcase vent hoses, a few brackets and the bolts are out. Let the engine cool fully, and wear eye protection while you scrape, because old gasket bits and grime fall straight down.
Clean both sealing surfaces until dry without gouging them, seat the new gasket in the cover, lower it straight down and start the bolts by hand. Tighten them in the sequence and to the figure in the service manual, using an inch-pound torque wrench like those in our torque wrench guide for DIY work instead of guessing by feel.

While the cover is off, check the crankcase vent hoses. A blocked vent builds pressure and pushes oil past any seal, so a new gasket alone will not stop that leak. A cracked hose on the intake side can also let in unmetered air and leave the engine stumbling, which our article on a car that hesitates when accelerating walks through.
West Michigan winters are hard on an old 4.0 gasket. Rubber baked on the engine for years shrinks in the cold, so a seep in August can drip in January, and salt grime sticks to the oily head. Degrease first so the real leak path shows.
When the Drip Is Not the Valve Cover
Oil runs downhill, so a wet engine does not prove the valve cover is to blame. Also suspect the oil filter adapter, oil pan gasket and rear main seal. A burning smell after a drive usually means oil is landing on the exhaust manifold, which sits right below the cover on the driver’s side.

Many owners searching for the best valve cover gasket for Jeep 4.0 repairs also have a warning light to sort out. If yours is lit, our check engine light diagnostic in Grand Rapids reads the codes and traces the cause, and we can look for leaks during an oil change at our Creston shop. If the Jeep drives normally with the light on, read about a check engine light that stays on while the car runs fine.
The 4.0 meters air with a manifold pressure sensor, not a mass air flow sensor, so if a newer car of yours has a MAF code, see our look at the best mass air flow sensor brand compares the main makers.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a rubber or cork valve cover gasket better on a Jeep 4.0?
Most owners prefer molded rubber because it holds its shape and is less likely to split when the bolts are snugged down. Cork-rubber compresses well and can seal a slightly uneven surface. Either works if the surfaces are clean and the bolts go to the manual torque.
Does a 1995 and a 1997 Jeep 4.0 use the same valve cover gasket?
No. The listings here split at the 1995 and 1996 model years, with 1987-1995 engines on the VS 50522 T style gasket and 1996-2006 engines on the VS 50458 R style set. Check the year and the old gasket before you buy.
Should I replace the valve cover grommets too?
On a 1996-2006 engine, yes, if the set does not already include them. Old grommets go hard and stop holding the bolts evenly, which can let a new gasket leak at the bolt holes.
Do I need RTV with a Jeep 4.0 valve cover gasket?
Only where the service manual or gasket instructions call for it. Extra sealant on a molded gasket can push it out of its groove, so follow the paperwork that comes with the set.
Can’t tell whether that oil is coming from the valve cover or somewhere lower? Ring us at 616-279-3832 between 8am and 5pm, Monday through Friday, or pick a time on our contact page.
If your workday overlaps our hours, the after-hours drop-off at 456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, lets you leave the Jeep when it suits you.
