As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.
Toyota owners usually go shopping for a converter for one of two reasons: a P0420 code that won’t go away, or a sawed-off pipe after a night parked outside. Either way, the best aftermarket catalytic converter for Toyota trucks and cars is a direct-fit part built for your exact model and engine, carrying the right emissions approval.
This guide covers the legal side first, then six direct-fit converters for the Tacoma, Tundra, 4Runner, Prius, Camry and RAV4. For universal units and other makes, start with our hub guide to the best aftermarket catalytic converter choices.
Quick answer
Which replacement converter should my Toyota get?
Read the emissions label under the hood, then buy a direct-fit unit listed for your model and engine. A federally certified 2.7L Tacoma can take MagnaFlow 24487, a 5.7L Tundra MagnaFlow 49935 and a 2004-2009 Prius Walker 16337. California-certified vehicles need a CARB-approved part such as MagnaFlow 447225.
Our Quick Picks
Three quick picks for the Toyotas that most often need a new converter: the four-cylinder Tacoma, the V8 Tundra and the 2004-2009 Prius. All six converters are reviewed below.

MagnaFlow 24487
A bolt-in converter shaped for the four-cylinder Tacoma's factory exhaust.

MagnaFlow 49935
A federal replacement for the second-generation Tundra's V8 exhaust.

Walker Ultra EPA 16337
A bolt-on Walker replacement for the second-generation Prius.
EPA or CARB: Let the Under-Hood Label Decide
Every Toyota carries an emissions control information label, usually on the underside of the hood or on the radiator support. It states whether the vehicle was certified to federal (EPA) standards, California standards or both, and it lists the engine family or test group. That label, not the state where you happen to live today, decides which replacement converter is legal.
The rule is simple in one direction. An EPA-compliant (federal) converter cannot be installed on a vehicle certified for California or for a state that enforces California’s CARB converter rules. The California Air Resources Board explains on its aftermarket catalytic converter page that a replacement must hold a CARB exemption, called an Executive Order, before it can be sold or installed there, and that each approval covers specific vehicles.
Michigan follows the federal rules and has not adopted California’s converter program. So a federally certified Toyota registered here can take an EPA converter that matches its application, and a Toyota with a California label should still get a CARB unit.
Why Direct-Fit Is the Usual Choice on a Toyota
A direct-fit converter copies the factory pipe shape, flanges, hangers and oxygen sensor bosses for a listed model. Walker describes its direct-fit converter range as built with OE-style hangers, brackets and heat shields, which is the point: the sensors land where the engine computer expects them. On a Toyota with sound studs, that often means a bolt-out, bolt-in swap.
Toyota fit splits finely by engine, cab and drive layout, so a few details matter before you order:
- Engine and position: V6 and V8 trucks run a converter on each bank, and some four-cylinder cars put the first converter inside the exhaust manifold.
- Cab and wheelbase: Tundra and Tacoma pipe lengths change with cab style, bed length and 2WD or 4WD.
- Grade: MagnaFlow sells OEM-grade and higher-loaded HM-grade direct-fit parts, and its CARB parts are a separate line.
Best Aftermarket Catalytic Converter for Toyota Models, Reviewed
The first three are MagnaFlow parts for Toyota trucks and SUVs, and the last three are Walker Ultra EPA parts for Toyota cars and the RAV4. Each one is listed for named models only, so confirm year, model, engine and emissions certification on Amazon before you buy.
1. MagnaFlow 24487: Direct-Fit Federal Catalytic Converter for Tacoma 2.7L

- Listed for 2005-2023 Tacoma 2.7L
- Federal/EPA compliant, HM grade
- Stainless spun body with mandrel-bent pipe
- OE-style O2 ports, hardware included
MagnaFlow lists this direct-fit converter for the 2005-2023 Toyota Tacoma with the 2.7L four-cylinder engine. That long run spans the second generation and much of the third, so a single part number covers a large share of four-cylinder Tacomas on the road. It is a federal (EPA) part, so it suits trucks whose emissions label shows federal certification, not California-only trucks.
The body is stainless steel in a spun shape, with mandrel-bent piping, flared receivers and oxygen sensor ports placed to mimic the original part. MagnaFlow says the shape comes from 3D scanning of the factory unit and that all required hardware is in the box. It is built to the maker’s HM grade, which MagnaFlow describes as carrying extra catalyst to improve the conversion of unwanted emissions.
In practice this suits a Tacoma owner whose original converter has failed after the cause was fixed, or one replacing a converter lost to theft. It is not meant for the V6 trucks, which use different converters on each bank. Confirm your year, cab, drive and engine on Amazon before buying, and read the label under your hood. On a salt-belt truck, expect to fight the flange studs.
View MagnaFlow 24487 on Amazon
2. MagnaFlow 49935: Direct-Fit OEM-Grade Catalytic Converter for Tundra V8

- Listed for 2010-2019 Tundra 4.6L
- Listed for 2007-2021 Tundra 5.7L
- Federal/EPA compliant, OEM grade
- Stainless spun body, hardware included
This MagnaFlow part is listed for the second-generation Toyota Tundra, covering the 2010-2019 trucks with the 4.6L V8 and the 2007-2021 trucks with the 5.7L V8. Those V8s run a converter on each bank, and the Tundra came in several cab and bed combinations, so the exact position and pipe length this number replaces matter. Read the listing notes on side, cab and wheelbase before you order, and check whether you need one unit or a pair.
MagnaFlow builds it to its OEM grade, meaning the catalyst load is meant to match the original part rather than exceed it. The construction follows the brand’s direct-fit pattern: a stainless spun body, mandrel-bent pipe, flared receivers and sensor ports placed where the factory put them. MagnaFlow states it is federal (EPA) compliant and ships with the required hardware, which saves sourcing gaskets and bolts separately.
It suits a federally certified Tundra with a healthy engine and a converter that has failed or been stolen. A truck with a California emissions label needs a CARB part instead. Tundras that tow or idle a lot in cold weather work their converters hard, so a misfire or rough idle should be fixed before the new converter goes in. Confirm your year, engine, cab and drive on Amazon first.
View MagnaFlow 49935 on Amazon

3. MagnaFlow 447225: CARB-Compliant Direct-Fit Catalytic Converter for 4Runner 3.4L

- Listed for 1999-2002 4Runner 3.4L
- California/CARB compliant
- Stainless clamshell body, seam welded
- Direct-fit with OE-style sensor ports
Not every Toyota in Michigan was certified to federal rules. Trucks bought used from California or other CARB states often carry a California emissions label, and those need a converter with a CARB Executive Order. MagnaFlow 447225 is that kind of part, listed for the 1999-2002 Toyota 4Runner with the 3.4L V6, the last years of the third-generation SUV.
The listing describes a clamshell body in stainless steel with a continuous seam weld, mandrel-bent pipe and oxygen sensor ports in the original positions. MagnaFlow says the unit is tested to meet California standards and those of other states that adopt them, and it asks buyers to verify fit and the engine family number before purchase. That last step matters, because a CARB approval only covers the engine families named in its Executive Order.
This is the pick for an older 4Runner whose label calls for CARB parts, or an owner who wants the stricter part on a truck certified to both standards. A federally certified 4Runner can legally use a federal converter instead. Rust is the usual enemy on trucks of this age, so expect the shop to cut out seized hardware. Confirm your year, engine, drive and emissions label on Amazon first.
View MagnaFlow 447225 CARB on Amazon
4. Walker Ultra EPA 16337: Direct-Fit Catalytic Converter for 2004-2009 Prius

- Listed for 2004-2009 Prius
- EPA compliant for 1996 and newer OBDII
- OE-style hangers, brackets and heat shield
- 2 in outlet, bolt-on design
The second-generation Prius is one of the cars converter thieves know well, so many owners shop for a replacement after finding a cut pipe rather than a failure code. Walker lists the Ultra EPA 16337 for the 2004-2009 Toyota Prius. It is a direct-fit, bolt-on part with a 2 inch outlet, so it is meant to go in without cutting or welding when the mounting hardware is sound.
Walker’s Ultra line uses an OE-style washcoat and a precious metal load matched to the application. The listing points out thick OE-style flanges, hangers and brackets, plus an aluminized heat shield where the original had one. Walker states that it is EPA compliant for OBDII vehicles from 1996 on and asks buyers to check their state’s aftermarket converter rules.
It suits a federally certified Prius whose hybrid system and engine are otherwise healthy. A Prius with a California emissions label needs a CARB-approved part, and the later 2010-2015 Prius uses a different converter. If yours was stolen, check the oxygen sensor wiring and nearby pipe for damage from the saw. Use the Amazon fit tool with your year and trim before you buy, and think about a shield or a garage.
View Walker Ultra EPA 16337 on Amazon

5. Walker Ultra EPA 16498: Direct-Fit Manifold Catalytic Converter for Camry

- Listed for 2007-2009 Camry
- Also listed for 2006-2008 Solara
- Integrated exhaust manifold design
- EPA compliant, OE-style heat shields
Some Toyota cars put the first converter right at the engine, built into the exhaust manifold. Walker’s Ultra EPA 16498 is that type of part, listed for the 2007-2009 Toyota Camry and the 2006-2008 Solara. It bolts to the cylinder head and connects to the downstream pipe, replacing the manifold and the converter as one assembly.
The listing calls it a bolt-off, bolt-on design with thick OE-style flanges and a manifold that matches all downstream connections. As with the rest of the Ultra line, Walker uses an OE-style washcoat and a precious metal load meant for the application, plus an aluminized heat shield where the factory fitted one. Walker states the part is EPA compliant for OBDII vehicles from 1996 on.
Because it mounts to the head, this is a bigger job than a pipe-mounted converter. Manifold studs can snap, and new gaskets and fasteners should be on hand before the old part comes off. A Camry with a cracked manifold or a failing front converter is the right match, but engine and body style matter. Confirm your year, engine and trim on Amazon, and check your emissions label for federal certification.
View Walker Ultra EPA 16498 on Amazon
6. Walker Ultra EPA 16849: Direct-Fit Catalytic Converter for 2013-2018 RAV4

- Listed for 2013-2018 RAV4
- EPA compliant for 1996 and newer OBDII
- OE-style hangers, brackets and heat shield
- Bolt-on, no welding required
The fourth-generation RAV4 is a popular compact SUV, and many of them are now old enough to need exhaust work. Walker lists the Ultra EPA 16849 for the 2013-2018 Toyota RAV4. It is a direct-fit, bolt-on part that copies the original routing, so it is designed to install without welding or custom fabrication.
Walker builds the Ultra line with an OE-style high-technology washcoat and a precious metal load meant to bring tailpipe emissions to the level required for the application. The listing highlights OE-style hangers, brackets and an aluminized heat shield where the original had one. It is labeled EPA compliant for OBDII vehicles from 1996 on, with a note to check state rules on aftermarket converters.
This part suits a federally certified gas RAV4 whose converter has failed or been taken. The 2019 and later redesign uses a different part, and hybrid versions should be checked separately, so match your model carefully. Before you buy, confirm year, engine and trim with the Amazon fit tool and read any blue information notes on the listing. A RAV4 with a California label needs a CARB-approved converter instead.
View Walker Ultra EPA 16849 on Amazon
Toyota Converters Side by Side
Find your model in the first column, then check that the emissions rating matches the label under your hood.
| Converter | Listed Toyota fit | Emissions rating | Install notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| MagnaFlow 24487 | 2005-2023 Tacoma 2.7L | Federal/EPA, HM grade | Direct-fit, hardware included |
| MagnaFlow 49935 | 2010-2019 Tundra 4.6L, 2007-2021 Tundra 5.7L | Federal/EPA, OEM grade | Direct-fit, check cab and wheelbase notes |
| MagnaFlow 447225 | 1999-2002 4Runner 3.4L | CARB | Direct-fit for CARB-label trucks |
| Walker Ultra EPA 16337 | 2004-2009 Prius | Federal/EPA | Direct-fit, 2 in outlet |
| Walker Ultra EPA 16498 | 2007-2009 Camry, 2006-2008 Solara | Federal/EPA | Bolts to the cylinder head as a manifold unit |
| Walker Ultra EPA 16849 | 2013-2018 RAV4 | Federal/EPA | Direct-fit with OE-style hangers |

Theft, Shields and Salt on West Michigan Toyotas
Tall pickups leave room to crawl underneath, and hybrid converters work less hard, so both attract thieves who want the precious metals inside. If yours was cut off, a replacement is only half the job. A bolt-on catalytic converter shield for the Tacoma or Tundra, a well-lit parking spot and a garage when you can get one all make the next attempt slower and noisier.

Salt also attacks the parts a direct-fit converter bolts to. After a few Grand Rapids winters, flange studs can fuse and hangers can rot, and a planned bolt-in job turns into cutting out seized hardware. Our guide to the best exhaust repair kit options covers short-term fixes for small leaks away from the converter. Any leak ahead of the downstream oxygen sensor can still trip a code, and our page on exhaust leak symptoms lists the signs.
When a New Converter Is a Job for Our Shop
Converters rarely fail on their own. A misfire, an engine that burns oil or a coolant leak can overheat or coat the new catalyst, and our guide to bad catalytic converter symptoms explains how to tell a failing unit from an upstream fault.

A P0420 can also come from a tired sensor, as our article on bad oxygen sensor symptoms shows. Before spending on a part, it is worth reading whether catalytic converter cleaners work for your situation. Even the best aftermarket catalytic converter for Toyota engines will set the code again if the root cause is still there.
For most owners, the swap itself is shop work: seized studs need heat, oxygen sensors often need special sockets and the truck needs to be safely lifted. Our exhaust repair in Grand Rapids service handles converters, pipes, hangers and mufflers on foreign and domestic vehicles. We confirm the code, check for leaks and test the sensors before any converter is ordered.
More Buying Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I install an EPA converter on my Toyota in Michigan?
Yes, if the emissions label under the hood shows the vehicle is federally certified. Michigan follows the federal rules. If the label shows California certification only, choose a CARB-approved converter with an Executive Order that covers your vehicle.
Does a Tundra V8 need one converter or two?
V8 Tundras run a converter on each bank of the engine. Some listings sell a single side and others sell a left and right pair, so read the description and the fit notes on cab and wheelbase before ordering.
Is a catalytic converter shield worth it on a Tacoma or Prius?
A shield makes theft slower and louder, which is often enough to send a thief elsewhere. It adds a plate that can trap salt and slush, so rinse it in winter and check the bolts each spring.
Will a new aftermarket converter clear my P0420 code?
Only if the old converter was the real fault. A misfire, oil burning, an exhaust leak or a weak downstream oxygen sensor can set the same code, and those problems will return it on a new part.
Got a P0420 on your Tacoma or a cut pipe under your Prius? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, or ask for a converter and exhaust check through our contact page.
Can’t get away from work? Park your Toyota at 456 Carrier St NE after hours, drop the key with a short note on the code or noise, so it is waiting in our lot when the shop opens.
