456 Carrier St NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505 Mon to Fri, 8:00am to 5:00pm. After-hours drop-off available 456autofix@gmail.com

Accord, CR-V or Civic? Choosing the Best Catalytic Converter for Honda Cars

best catalytic converter for honda: aerial view of a winding road through lush green tea plantations

As an Amazon Associate, 456 AutoFix earns from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon, where you can confirm the right part for your vehicle.

A Honda that has passed 150,000 miles can still run beautifully, but the catalytic converter is often the part that finally lights up the dash. The best catalytic converter for Honda owners is not a single product. It is a direct-fit unit built for your model, your engine and your emissions label, from a maker that publishes its fit data.

This guide sorts out the legal questions, explains why some Honda converters live inside the exhaust manifold, then reviews six converters for the Accord, CR-V, Civic and Element. For universal units and other brands of car, our hub on the best aftermarket catalytic converter options covers the wider market.

Quick answer

Which catalytic converter should I buy for my Honda?

Buy a direct-fit converter listed for your exact year, model and engine, with the emissions rating your hood label calls for. A federal 2008-2012 Accord 2.4L can take MagnaFlow 49896, a 2007-2009 CR-V the Walker Ultra EPA 53782, and a California-certified 2006-2011 Civic the Walker CalCat CARB 83495.

Our Quick Picks

Three quick picks for the Hondas that most often need a converter: the four-cylinder Accord, the CR-V and a California-label Civic. All six converters are reviewed below.

MagnaFlow 49896 product photo
Accord 2008-2012

MagnaFlow 49896

Direct-fit · Federal/EPA · 2.4L

A bolt-in federal converter for the eighth-generation four-cylinder Accord.

SuitsFederally certified 2008-2012 Accord 2.4L
View on Amazon →
Walker Ultra EPA 53782 product photo
CR-V 2007-2009

Walker Ultra EPA 53782

Direct-fit · Federal/EPA

A bolt-on federal converter for the early third-generation CR-V.

SuitsFederally certified 2007-2009 CR-V
View on Amazon →
Walker CalCat CARB 83495 product photo
Civic CARB

Walker CalCat CARB 83495

Direct-fit · CARB · EO D-182-70

A California-approved converter for the eighth-generation Civic.

Suits2006-2011 Civic with a California emissions label
View on Amazon →

Federal, California and Michigan: Sorting Out the Rules

Open the hood and look for the vehicle emission control information sticker, usually on the hood underside or near the radiator. It says whether your Honda was certified to federal standards, California standards or both.

Michigan uses the federal rules for aftermarket converters rather than California’s program. The EPA’s consumer fact sheet on using, installing or buying aftermarket catalytic converters lists three cases where an aftermarket unit may go on: the old converter is missing, an inspection program has found it needs replacing, or the vehicle is past its emissions warranty period and the need is documented. For 1995 and newer vehicles, that period is 8 years or 80,000 miles.

The same fact sheet asks for the replacement to sit in the original location and be the same type as the original. It also notes that converters built for California meet EPA requirements, because California’s standards are stricter. So a CARB unit is fine on a federal Honda, but an EPA unit is the wrong choice for a Honda with a California-only label.

A younger Honda with a failed converter may still be covered by the factory emissions warranty, so check that before you buy anything.

Manifold Converter or Underbody Converter?

Many four-cylinder Hondas use two catalysts. The first sits right at the engine, often built into the exhaust manifold, so it heats up fast after a cold start. A second one, sometimes called the center or rear converter, sits under the car further down the pipe.

Before ordering, work out which one actually failed:

  • Code and sensor position: a P0420 points to bank 1, and the downstream oxygen sensor reading tells a technician which catalyst stopped storing oxygen.
  • Part description: a “manifold” or “with integrated exhaust manifold” listing bolts to the cylinder head. A plain direct-fit listing usually replaces a pipe section under the car.

Best Catalytic Converter for Honda: Six Direct-Fit Picks

Three Accord parts lead the list, followed by one for the CR-V, a CARB-approved Civic unit and one for the Element. Each listing names specific years and engines, so confirm year, model, engine and emissions label on Amazon before you buy.

1. MagnaFlow 49896: Direct-Fit Federal Catalytic Converter for 2008-2012 Accord 2.4L

MagnaFlow 49896 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for 2008-2012 Accord 2.4L
  • Federal/EPA compliant
  • 16-gauge 409 stainless steel tubing
  • Gaskets and hardware included

MagnaFlow 49896 is a direct-fit replacement converter listed for the 2008-2012 Honda Accord with the 2.4L four-cylinder engine. The same listing also names the 2009-2014 Acura TSX 2.4L, which shares much of its drivetrain with that Accord. It carries a federal (EPA) rating, so it is meant for cars whose emissions sticker shows federal certification rather than California-only certification.

MagnaFlow builds the pipework from 16-gauge 409 stainless steel, a grade chosen for corrosion resistance, and joins it with 308 stainless MIG welds. The maker says the part is designed to copy the factory unit’s flow so the engine keeps its original performance and fuel economy. Gaskets and the hardware needed for the swap come in the box, which saves a separate trip for bolts and seals.

This is the converter to look at when a four-cylinder Accord of this generation has a confirmed converter failure or has lost its converter to theft. It is not listed for the V6 Accord, which uses a different exhaust layout. Confirm your year, trim and engine on Amazon before ordering, and expect older studs on a salted Michigan car to need penetrant or heat before they come loose.

View MagnaFlow 49896 on Amazon

2. Walker Ultra EPA 55715: Direct-Fit Catalytic Converter for 2013-2017 Honda Accord

Walker Ultra EPA 55715 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for 2013-2017 Accord
  • EPA compliant for OBDII vehicles
  • OE-style flanges, hangers and brackets
  • Aluminized heat shields where fitted

The Walker Ultra EPA 55715 is a direct-fit converter that Walker lists for the 2013-2017 Honda Accord, the ninth generation. Ultra EPA is Walker’s federal line, designed for OBDII vehicles from 1996 onward. Walker’s own wording tells buyers to check their state’s aftermarket converter rules, and Michigan follows the federal ones, so a federally certified Accord here is the intended application.

The part is a bolt-on design with OE-style hangers, brackets and routing, so it is meant to go in without welding or custom fabrication. Walker uses thick flanges for strength and fits aluminized heat shields where the factory part had them, which protects the underbody and nearby parts from converter heat. The maker describes the washcoat and precious metal load as matched to the vehicle application.

Because the listing names the model years but not every engine and trim, take the time to enter your full vehicle details on Amazon and read any qualifier notes before you buy. Once fit is confirmed, this is a sensible choice for an Accord that has a verified converter fault or a cut exhaust after a theft.

View Walker Ultra EPA 55715 on Amazon

gravel and asphalt road through lush greenery

3. MagnaFlow 27405: HM Grade Direct-Fit Converter for 2003-2007 Accord 2.4L

MagnaFlow 27405 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for 2003-2007 Accord 2.4L
  • Federal/EPA compliant, HM grade
  • Spun stainless body, mandrel-bent pipe
  • 5-year/50,000-mile limited warranty

MagnaFlow lists the 27405 for the 2003-2007 Honda Accord with the 2.4L four-cylinder. Plenty of these seventh-generation cars are still on the road with high mileage, which is exactly when converters tend to give out. The part is federal (EPA) compliant, so it suits Accords with a federal emissions sticker, and MagnaFlow asks buyers to confirm fitment before purchase.

MagnaFlow says it uses 3D scanning of the original part to shape this converter, and it includes all the hardware needed for the swap. The body is a spun stainless steel design with mandrel-bent piping, flared receivers and oxygen sensor ports placed where the factory ones were. It is built to MagnaFlow’s HM grade, which the maker describes as carrying extra catalyst for better conversion of unwanted emissions.

The listing includes a 5-year or 50,000-mile limited warranty on construction and emissions, in line with what EPA expects from new aftermarket converters. It suits an older four-cylinder Accord whose converter has been confirmed as the fault after misfires or oil burning were ruled out. It is not intended for the V6 Accord of the same years. Check year, engine and transmission notes on Amazon before you buy.

View MagnaFlow 27405 on Amazon

4. Walker Ultra EPA 53782: Direct-Fit Catalytic Converter for 2007-2009 Honda CR-V

Walker Ultra EPA 53782 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for 2007-2009 CR-V
  • EPA compliant for OBDII vehicles
  • Bolt-on, no welding required
  • OE-style washcoat and metal load

The Walker Ultra EPA 53782 is listed for the 2007-2009 Honda CR-V, the first years of the third-generation model. Part number 53782 is also the reference several other brands quote for their CR-V center converters, which helps when you are matching it against the part on your car. It is a federal (EPA) converter for OBDII vehicles, so it belongs on a CR-V with federal certification.

Walker designs it as a direct bolt-on part with OE-style hangers, brackets, routing and heat shields, so a correctly fitted unit should line up with the existing pipes without cutting. The flanges and brackets are thick, OE-style pieces, and aluminized heat shields are included where the original had them. Walker says the washcoat and precious metal load are matched to the application to deliver the required emissions reduction.

This suits a CR-V owner whose code points to the converter under the car rather than a manifold catalyst. On a CR-V that has seen many Michigan winters, the flange bolts and nearby pipe can be badly rusted, so budget for replacement hardware. Use Amazon’s fit tool with your full vehicle details and read any notes before buying, because later CR-V years use different parts.

View Walker Ultra EPA 53782 on Amazon

close-up of soldering process with tools in electronics assembly

5. Walker CalCat CARB 83495: Direct-Fit Converter for 2006-2011 Honda Civic

Walker CalCat CARB 83495 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for 2006-2011 Civic
  • CARB compliant, EO D-182-70
  • 2.25 in outlet, bolt-on design
  • Stainless body with aluminized pipe

The Walker CalCat CARB 83495 is a direct-fit converter listed for the 2006-2011 Honda Civic. CalCat is Walker’s California line, and this part carries California Air Resources Board Executive Order D-182-70, which the listing quotes. That makes it the pick here for a Civic whose emissions sticker shows California certification, a situation that comes up when a car is bought in or moved from a CARB state.

Walker builds it as a bolt-on replacement with OE-style hangers, brackets, routing and heat shields, so it should not need welding or fabrication. The body is stainless steel with aluminized pipe and heat shields, and the outlet measures 2.25 inches. Walker says its CalCat coating process applies the catalyst consistently and that the washcoat is formulated to outperform its EPA-compliant converters.

Because California converters also meet federal requirements, a CARB unit is a legal option on a federally certified Civic too, although it usually costs more than an EPA part. The Civic of these years came in several versions, including the Si and hybrid, so confirm your engine and trim with Amazon’s fit tool and read the qualifier notes. Replace oxygen sensors only if testing shows they are slow or damaged.

View Walker CalCat CARB 83495 on Amazon

6. MagnaFlow 51990: Direct-Fit Federal Catalytic Converter for 2003-2011 Element 2.4L

MagnaFlow 51990 product photo
Key features
  • Listed for 2003-2011 Element 2.4L
  • Federal/EPA compliant
  • Mandrel-bent 409 stainless tubing
  • Gaskets and hardware included

MagnaFlow 51990 is listed for the Honda Element from 2003 through 2011 with the 2.4L engine, which covers the whole production run of the model in the US. Many Elements are now high-mileage vehicles, and owners who plan to keep them often face a converter replacement at some point. The part is federal (EPA) compliant, so it suits an Element with federal certification on its emissions sticker.

The tubing is mandrel-bent 16-gauge 409 stainless steel, which MagnaFlow uses for corrosion resistance and a long service life. Mandrel bending keeps the pipe diameter even through the bends, and the maker says the design keeps factory-like flow, performance and fuel economy. The essential gaskets and hardware are included in the box, so the swap does not depend on reusing old, stretched bolts.

This is a good match for an Element owner whose converter has been confirmed as failed after misfires and sensor faults were checked. Some Elements were sold with different drive layouts, so enter your year, drive type and engine in Amazon’s fit tool and read any notes before ordering. On an Element that has spent many winters on salted roads, check the pipes on both ends of the converter as well.

View MagnaFlow 51990 on Amazon

Honda Converter Fit at a Glance

ConverterListed Honda fitEmissions ratingNotes
MagnaFlow 498962008-2012 Accord 2.4LFederal/EPAAlso listed for 2009-2014 Acura TSX 2.4L
Walker Ultra EPA 557152013-2017 AccordFederal/EPACheck engine and trim notes on the listing
MagnaFlow 274052003-2007 Accord 2.4LFederal/EPA, HM gradeSpun stainless body, hardware included
Walker Ultra EPA 537822007-2009 CR-VFederal/EPAOE-style hangers and heat shields
Walker CalCat CARB 834952006-2011 CivicCARB, EO D-182-70For California-label cars; also legal on federal cars
MagnaFlow 519902003-2011 Element 2.4LFederal/EPA409 stainless tubing, gaskets included
Honda fitment and emissions ratings as each Amazon listing states them; confirm your year, engine and emissions label before ordering
tranquil forest scene featuring tall pine trees and a winding dirt path leading into the distance

Theft, Road Salt and Grand Rapids Winters

Converter theft hits plenty of Hondas, because the parts are easy to reach and hold valuable metals. If yours was cut off, the replacement is only part of the fix: you will often need new pipe sections, and possibly new oxygen sensors if the wiring was cut. Parking in a garage or a well-lit spot helps, and a bolt-on shield slows a thief down. Our review of the best catalytic converter shield for Prius models explains how those plates work, even though the fit there is Toyota-specific.

serene rural road surrounded by mist and countryside trees

West Michigan salt is the other enemy. After several winters on brined roads, the studs that hold a direct-fit converter can rust solid, and a simple bolt-in job may need heat or cutting. A small pinhole away from the converter can sometimes be patched for a while, and our guide to the best exhaust repair kit products covers tapes, pastes and clamps. A leak upstream of the rear oxygen sensor can still upset the readings, so read up on exhaust leak symptoms before you blame the converter.

Before You Order: Diagnose First, Then Replace

A converter usually fails because something upstream damaged it. Misfires send unburned fuel into the catalyst and overheat it, and an engine burning oil or coolant coats it until it stops working. Our article on bad catalytic converter symptoms lists the signs that separate a dead converter from an engine fault.

drone shot on the road

A lazy downstream sensor can also set P0420 on a healthy converter, which is covered in our guide to bad oxygen sensor symptoms. Even the best catalytic converter for Honda engines will fail again if a misfire or oil leak is still there.

For most drivers, fitting a converter is a shop job, with seized studs and delicate sensors to deal with. Our exhaust repair in Grand Rapids covers converters, pipes, hangers and mufflers, and we check codes, sensor data and leaks before recommending a new converter.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I put an EPA catalytic converter on my Honda in Michigan?

Yes, as long as the emissions sticker under the hood shows federal certification and the converter is listed for your year and engine. Michigan follows the federal aftermarket converter rules. A Honda certified only for California should get a CARB-approved converter instead.

What is the best catalytic converter for Honda Accord models?

It depends on the generation. MagnaFlow lists 27405 for the 2003-2007 Accord 2.4L and 49896 for the 2008-2012 Accord 2.4L, and Walker lists its Ultra EPA 55715 for the 2013-2017 Accord. V6 Accords use different converters, so check the engine first.

Do I need new oxygen sensors with a new converter?

Not always. If the sensors read correctly and come out cleanly, they can move to the new converter. Sensors that are slow, damaged or seized in a rusty bung are worth replacing at the same time.

Why did my P0420 come back after a new converter?

Usually because the original cause was never fixed. Misfires, oil burning, an exhaust leak or a weak downstream sensor can all trigger the code again. A converter that is not listed for your exact engine can also set it.

Is your Honda showing a P0420 or sounding like a race car after a theft? Call 456 AutoFix at 616-279-3832, Monday to Friday 8am to 5pm, or set up a converter diagnosis through our contact page.

Working the same hours we do? Leave your Honda in our lot at 456 Carrier St NE using after-hours drop-off, with a note about the warning light or noise, so it is waiting for us when the shop opens.